pybliometrics-dev / pybliometrics

Python-based API-Wrapper to access Scopus
https://pybliometrics.readthedocs.io/en/stable/
Other
410 stars 128 forks source link

[BUG] Paper published in 2021 has citations dated before 1900 #206

Closed raffaem closed 2 years ago

raffaem commented 3 years ago

The following paper with scopus ID 85100910856 was published in 2021, as can be seen on the scopus page, but has citations dated before 1900:

>>> res = CitationOverview(identifier=["85100910856"], start=1900)
>>> print(res.pcc)
[1]
Michael-E-Rose commented 3 years ago

I cannot replicate this. For me this looks like

>>> res = CitationOverview(identifier=["85100910856"], start=1900)
>>> print(res.pcc)
[0]

However, it actually does happend that citation occur before the document is published:

  1. Citations from the year or the two years before is normal IMO as the publication lag can be very lengthy
  2. Books are indexed by year of online publication, not actual publication; Actual citations thush look like they occurred before Scopus says the book was published
  3. There are also errors in the publication date information on Scopus; if this is the case, have them corrected via the Scopus web form.
raffaem commented 2 years ago

I confirm that I continue to obtain [1] and with refresh=True I now obtain 0.

Why was the data before the refresh wrong?


What do you mean by

Books are indexed by year of online publication, not actual publication

?

Michael-E-Rose commented 2 years ago

I cannot say why the data was wrong before the refresh. Perhaps there was a wrong entry on Scopus (i.e., a wrong publication year of a citing document) and they fixed it since you first requested the information.


I meant "publication year". For some reason beyond my understanding, the coverDate of a book or book chapter in Scopus is the year the book or book chapter got published online. All other people would use the year the book was actually published.

That's why Wassily Leontief (Economics Nobel Prize in 1973) has four publications (books and book chapters) published after his death in 1999.