search

pypa / packaging-problems

An issue tracker for the problems in packaging
140 stars 33 forks source link

Classifiers and when to use which ones #31

Open dstufft opened 10 years ago

dstufft commented 10 years ago

There is confusion about what some of them mean and when you should use them. Currently there is no explanation about what the classifiers mean or should be used for, just a massive list of them.

One example is the natural language ones If a project is coded in English and the primary language of the project/community is English, should they add a Language classifier to it or do those classifiers only apply to things that do natural language processing?

alex commented 10 years ago

From the flipside: classifiers are basically useless as a consumer, I never read them, I just read the prose.

eevee commented 10 years ago

I don't know who decided on the classifiers, either. Are they even possible to use as a search filter?

Occasionally a project doesn't mention Python versions in the README, but does use versioned classifiers. Other than that I've never really looked at them either.

r1chardj0n3s commented 10 years ago

Classifiers seemed like a good idea and were inspired by similar systems at the time like freshmeat.net (you kids probably don't remember that, lol). The list of Trove classifiers were derived from freshmeat's and some others from the FSF IIRC.

Seemed like a good idea, at the time. This was before tagging got organised.

They are searchable, using the "browse" pages. This is not combined with a text search though. I understand some projects use this facility to display a list of packages related to them.

I like the idea of replacing the Trove stuff with a smart tagging system, but it's hard to give users tag suggestions (to help curate the morass) when they're submitting via "setup.py upload" or similar mechanisms. Hence the restricted set dictated by PyPI.

brainwane commented 6 years ago

@jonparrott as far as you know, is this the kind of thing that could or ought to go into the Python Packaging User Guide?

theacodes commented 6 years ago

Absolutely

On Mon, Mar 12, 2018, 6:49 PM Sumana Harihareswara notifications@github.com wrote:

@jonparrott https://github.com/jonparrott as far as you know, is this the kind of thing that could or ought to go into the Python Packaging User Guide?

— You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/pypa/packaging-problems/issues/31#issuecomment-372519212, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAPUc8paMcXziDD1y3UB4sMJ1XPsPYC-ks5tdyWhgaJpZM4BKiY- .