Ctypes: Unclear Error Message for WinFunctionType Mismatch in Windows API Calls

songyuc commented 1 month ago

Description:

When working with Windows API functions (such as SetWindowsHookExW) using ctypes, providing a HOOKPROC callback function of an incorrect type results in an unclear error message. This can be confusing, especially for beginners or when debugging complex scenarios.

Current error message: TypeError: expected WinFunctionType instance instead of WinFunctionType

Suggested improved error message: TypeError: expected WinFunctionType with signature (restype=wintypes.LPARAM, argtypes=[ctypes.c_int32, wintypes.WPARAM, wintypes.LPARAM]) but received WinFunctionType with signature (restype=ctypes.c_int, argtypes=[ctypes.c_int, wintypes.WPARAM, wintypes.LPARAM])

Steps to Reproduce:

Create a Python script with the following content:

import ctypes
import ctypes.wintypes

HOOKPROC = ctypes.WINFUNCTYPE(ctypes.c_int, ctypes.c_int, ctypes.wintypes.WPARAM, ctypes.wintypes.LPARAM)

user32 = ctypes.windll.user32
user32.SetWindowsHookExW.argtypes = [ctypes.c_int, HOOKPROC, ctypes.wintypes.HINSTANCE, ctypes.wintypes.DWORD]
user32.SetWindowsHookExW.restype = ctypes.wintypes.HHOOK

def callback(nCode, wParam, lParam):
    return user32.CallNextHookEx(None, nCode, wParam, lParam)

pointer = HOOKPROC(callback)
hook_id = user32.SetWindowsHookExW(13, pointer, None, 0)  # 13 corresponds to WH_KEYBOARD_LL

# At this point, import pynput, which modifies the SetWindowsHookExW function
from pynput import keyboard, mouse

# Attempt to set the hook again, which now fails due to type mismatch
hook_id = user32.SetWindowsHookExW(13, pointer, None, 0)

Run the script

Expected Result: A clear error message indicating the mismatch between the expected and provided WinFunctionType, including details about their signatures.

Actual Result: An unclear error message: "TypeError: expected WinFunctionType instance instead of WinFunctionType"

Python Version: 3.12.7 Operating System: Windows

Suggested Improvement: Modify the logic in ctypes that generates these error messages to include more detailed information about the expected and actual WinFunctionType instances, such as their return types and argument types. This would greatly improve the readability and usefulness of the error message, especially for beginners and when debugging complex scenarios.

Additional Notes: This issue becomes apparent when using libraries like pynput that modify Windows API function signatures. A more descriptive error message would help users identify and resolve such conflicts more easily.

CPython versions tested on:

3.12

Operating systems tested on:

Windows

zooba commented 1 month ago

Improving an error message is a feature, not a bug, but there shouldn't be any reason why it can't be done here (it just won't be backported to maintenance releases).

(The bugfix in pynput (or the user's own code) is to use ctypes.WinDLL("user32") rather than ctypes.windll.user32 so that they aren't modifying shared objects. This should already be documented, I'm pretty sure.)

songyuc commented 1 month ago

Improving an error message is a feature, not a bug, but there shouldn't be any reason why it can't be done here (it just won't be backported to maintenance releases).

(The bugfix in pynput (or the user's own code) is to use ctypes.WinDLL("user32") rather than ctypes.windll.user32 so that they aren't modifying shared objects. This should already be documented, I'm pretty sure.)

Thanks sincerely for your guide!

python / cpython