The next tutorials

[msaroufim]

From our README.md

torchao is a library to create and integrate high-performance custom data types layouts into your PyTorch workflows

And so far we've done a good job building out the primitive data types along with their corresponding transformed Linear Layers so for example given a new ExoticDtype() we have a playbook to create ExoticDtypeLinear() and indeed for weight only transformations this is a perfectly fine workflow and how the majority of quantization libraries operate.

For example

m = DownloadModelFromHuggingFace()
m = quantize(m, int4_weight_only()) # This will swap out all torch.nn.Linear with a 4 bit Linear

We can make the above shine with more accessible blogs and performance benchmarks and integrations with more partners

However, this is doing somewhat of a disservice at explaining the ao value proposition. For example, we're a dtype library and not a dtype Linear library so given a dtype it should be easy for us to do a lot more. So some examples I'd like to see next are

• [ ] Quantized Optimizers with the most obvious additions being 8 bit and 4 bit ADAM
• [ ] Quantized KV cache
• [ ] Quantization Aware training with an exotic dtype

None of the above is "research", this is very much the way engineering is moving for inference https://blog.character.ai/optimizing-ai-inference-at-character-ai/

Also given an exotic quantization schema I'd like to be more proactive in helping people benchmark their models so this should include

• [ ] Flop utilization
• [ ] Memory bandwidth
• [ ] Cache hit rate (for kv cache only)
• [ ] Roofline analysis

[gau-nernst]

8-bit Adam from bitsandbytes. Resources for reference

• Paper: https://arxiv.org/abs/2110.02861
• Code:
  • https://github.com/TimDettmers/bitsandbytes/blob/main/csrc/kernels.cu (Adam 8-bit kernel https://github.com/TimDettmers/bitsandbytes/blob/dada530149212d64d4b69534716202659ef37ec8/csrc/kernels.cu#L1383-L1504)
  • https://github.com/TimDettmers/bitsandbytes/blob/main/bitsandbytes/functional.py

[jeromeku]

@msaroufim

Would love to work on this.

• Regarding 4-bit and 8-bit ADAM is this already done? I'd been working on a triton-only version of AdamW8-bit which could potentially serve as a drop-in replacement for the original CUDA version that would work more seamlessly with torch.compile and the rest of torchao primitives. Or are you thinking of integrating the original 8-bit version as a custom cuda op?
• Quantized KV-cache - lots of research in this area, given the importance of efficient (long-context) inference. Would this include methods that require training-time architectural changes (per the character.ai blog) or post-training (dynamic) methods? For the latter, I think some of the major buckets are KV cache offloading, compression / quantization, and eviction (i.e. token pruning). Could further categorize by methods that compress at the layer, head, token, and hidden dim level.
• Regarding profiling, happy to help here as well. Pretty familiar with torch.profiler as well as extending it for even more fine-grained metrics.

[msaroufim]

• Regarding 8 bit ADAM. I was thinking we'd try to code-generate this using int8_weight_only or the dynamically quantized version. So generally I want us to follow the heuristic of first try compile() and if that doesn't work then Triton and if that doesn't work then integrate the original as a custom op. I'd be fine if you need to integrate the original bnb kernel as a custom op if it makes testing in CI easier
• For the quantized KV cache I was specifically thinking about inference however we're starting to do more with quantization aware training (fake quantization) in collaboration with the tune team so you can chat with @andrewor14 https://github.com/pytorch/ao/pull/383 generally for these cross repo PRs I'd like to see them work in standalone examples in ao and we can refer to a more prod ready version in tune. Seems like we should also be moving towards quantized training (non fake)
• Yeah regarding profiling that'd be very helpful, I think people are having trouble figuring out how far they are away from roofline so some simple benchmark utils in torchao.utils or torchao.benchmark would do wonders

[jeromeku]

@msaroufim

RE: profiling

• what is the ideal set of metrics for this analysis?
• do you have some sample workloads that I could use as test cases while developing these utils

[msaroufim]

For metrics the most important ones are memory bandwidth and flop utilization. A good representative workload for now is probably llama2 and llama3 https://github.com/pytorch/ao/blob/main/torchao/_models/llama/generate.py and this script has good metric instrumentation already so extending it feels natural

And for specific algorithms to test out I'd be most curious about testing out

• @gau-nernst fpx work https://github.com/pytorch/ao/pull/399
• @vayuda intx work https://github.com/pytorch/ao/blob/main/torchao/prototype/common/bitpacking.py