Open pzl111 opened 10 months ago
Thank you for your feedback. 24:00
is not a valid time in any given scenario, and in our error message, we specify that we require HH:mm as a valid format, but 24
is an invalid hour, and thus is not a valid format. Documentation for HH:mm
can be found in Java Docs under Patterns for Formatting and Parsing:
https://docs.oracle.com/javase/8/docs/api/java/time/format/DateTimeFormatter.html
In addition, the screenshot below shows that we do not need to add in "nitty-gritty" details to the UG:
In this case, we decided to omit the detail that the 24th hour is in fact, invalid
Team chose [response.Rejected
]
Reason for disagreement: As you mentioned in your reply: "we require HH:mm as a valid format, but 24 is an invalid hour". Exactly, it is an invalid hour, not format. Furthermore I would not claim it as a "nitty-gritty" detail, since it is a wrong error. Perhaps asking to the group to tell the user that their "hour" is wrong would be a "nitty-gritty" request, but an invalid time would be a reasonable expectation.
typing
edit 1 dt/29-02-2000 24:00
tells me this:but it is correct format, just that 24:00 does not exist.