Problems editing wfs features QGIS

[newmarwegner]

What is the bug or the crash?

When create and save a new feature in wfs 2.0.0 feature connected in qgis 3.22, the feature its created, but when press the reload button, the point create have a displacement from the correct place. Open a new project and adding the feature again its possible to see that feature its not create at the right place. wfs connect feature created and save without reload in the right place wfs after press reload button

Steps to reproduce the issue

1. Connect wfs 2.0.0 qgis;
2. start editing wfs;
3. create a new point feature;
4. stop editing;
5. press reload button (in this step probably will see the displacement).

Versions

QGIS 3.22.4

Supported QGIS version

• [ ] I'm running a supported QGIS version according to the roadmap.

New profile

• [ ] I tried with a new QGIS profile

Additional context

No response

[klebersonrn]

Hello, I have the same problem, I had to download an old version of qgis, 3.10. Here the points do not move.

[elpaso]

Inverted axis?

[newmarwegner]

Inverted axis?

when try enable inverted axis in settings of connection give an error of extension incorrectly.

[newmarwegner]

Inverted axis?

In fact, when I check the coordinates they are inverted. Is there some way to solve this issue?

[michikommader]

I observe similar behaviour with QGIS 3.28.0 when editing a WGS84-referenced layer from GeoServer 2.21.2 via WFS-T. The layer is served through PostGIS.

GeoServer's getCapabilities() requests return the following SRS definitions for my layer of interest:

• WFS 1.0.0: EPSG:4326
• WFS 1.1.0: urn:x-ogc:def:crs:EPSG:4326
• WFS 2.0.0: urn:ogc:def:crs:EPSG::4326

Loading my layer in QGIS works well with all three WFS versions 1.0.0, 1.1.0, 2.0.0 with default QGIS settings (no axis inversion etc. selected). All geometries are rendered correctly. Thus, I suppose that both QGIS and GeoServer handle coordinate axis order correctly.

But when I toggle layer editing, draw a new feature and save/commit my change to GeoServer, the newly created geometry is written inconsistently:

• Using WFS 1.0.0, QGIS writes the correct axis order.
• Using WFS 1.1.0, QGIS writes the correct axis order.
• Using WFS 2.0.0, QGIS inverts the axis order.

I am aware of axis order issues on GeoServer-side. Looking at my GeoServer's getCapabilities() responses above, the SRS seems to be correctly defined. And also rendering of downloaded features works correctly with QGIS default settings. Thus, I suppose, that there is a problem when committing changes via WFS-T 2.0.0?

[krzysztof-adamski]

I have the same problem with WFS layer. In my opinion problem is not in edit mode - because modification attributes on layer depend on read-only layer on geoserver side.

True issue is when I trying reload WFS layer, by click - (reload action) on the table attributes. Then QGIS crashing sudenly.

I don't know how this issue shoul be resolve. Maybe disable layer to reload datasource.