pathmapper
commented
1 year ago Confirmed with QGIS 3.29.0-Master (2a0fc591f7).
Open ThomasG77 opened 1 year ago
pathmapper
commented
1 year ago Confirmed with QGIS 3.29.0-Master (2a0fc591f7).
elpaso
commented
1 year ago Two layers, same name? That's the root of the problem.
ThomasG77
commented
1 year ago I've confirmed the diagnostic with a capabilities version where I've renamed one of the 2 layers mentioned as AGENDA21_S_R44_DEBUG instead of AGENDA21_S_R44 and used the remote fixed static capabilities https://labs.webgeodatavore.com/partage/capabilities.xml?
Need to made a feedback to OGC web service owner about name duplication he should check.
Only thing that could be done on QGIS side seems to put a warning when finding layer(s) with duplicated layer(s) name(s) in WMS Data Source Manager panel or put a warning about this situation in QGIS doc.
Not sure if it needs more action on QGIS devs side and if need to be closed as wondering if this kind of issue should be caught at QGIS level or elsewhere.
PS: made a small tool only for this purpose e.g https://gist.github.com/ThomasG77/45567547728ad993aee9f4457760440a
alexbruy
commented
8 months ago Can be closed?
ThomasG77
commented
8 months ago Depend if you consider my suggestion (repeated below) mandatory otherwise, good to close at there is an answer
Only thing that could be done on QGIS side seems to put a warning when finding layer(s) with duplicated layer(s) name(s) in WMS Data Source Manager panel or put a warning about this situation in QGIS doc.
What is the bug or the crash?
With this project, https://github.com/qgis/QGIS/files/10076587/debug-qgis-ogc-wms.qgz.zip
The below WMS layer can't be queried (unable to activate the "Identify Feature" button for the layer) whereas GetFeatureInfo is possible (checked in the capabilities)
For layer "AGENDA21_S_R44" named in layer tree "Collectivites engagees dans une demarche Agenda 21 dans le Grand Est" with WMS URL https://ogc.geo-ide.developpement-durable.gouv.fr/wxs?map=/opt/data/carto/geoide-catalogue/1.4/org_5443264/ccf16ee8-5b97-4cf5-9257-c88102c106e2.internet.map
Manual GetFeatureInfo with text/plain
https://ogc.geo-ide.developpement-durable.gouv.fr/wxs?map=/opt/data/carto/geoide-catalogue/1.4/org_5443264/ccf16ee8-5b97-4cf5-9257-c88102c106e2.internet.map&SERVICE=WMS&VERSION=1.3.0&REQUEST=GetFeatureInfo&BBOX=880288.54028120101429522,6862834.76942052692174911,889264.71626451192423701,6871157.00023245997726917&CRS=EPSG:2154&WIDTH=1153&HEIGHT=1069&LAYERS=AGENDA21_S_R44&STYLES=&FORMAT=image/png&QUERY_LAYERS=AGENDA21_S_R44&INFO_FORMAT=text/plain&I=833&J=382&FEATURE_COUNT=10
Manual GetFeatureInfo with application/vnd.ogc.gml
https://ogc.geo-ide.developpement-durable.gouv.fr/wxs?map=/opt/data/carto/geoide-catalogue/1.4/org_5443264/ccf16ee8-5b97-4cf5-9257-c88102c106e2.internet.map&SERVICE=WMS&VERSION=1.3.0&REQUEST=GetFeatureInfo&BBOX=880288.54028120101429522,6862834.76942052692174911,889264.71626451192423701,6871157.00023245997726917&CRS=EPSG:2154&WIDTH=1153&HEIGHT=1069&LAYERS=AGENDA21_S_R44&STYLES=&FORMAT=image/png&QUERY_LAYERS=AGENDA21_S_R44&INFO_FORMAT=application/vnd.ogc.gml&I=833&J=382&FEATURE_COUNT=10
So, the issue is that "Identify Feature" should be activated for the layer whereas it does not
Steps to reproduce the issue
Clue: maybe related to nested layers e.g below image
Versions
Active Python plugins densityanalysis | 2022.9.14 DataPlotly | 3.9.2 contour | 2.0.10 sagaprovider | 2.12.99 db_manager | 0.1.20 processing | 2.12.99 MetaSearch | 0.3.5 grassprovider | 2.12.99
Supported QGIS version
New profile
Additional context
Not running a supported version because using conda that only comes with 3.22.11 at the moment.