search

qharley / Morgan

RepRAP Morgan scad source repository
92 stars 36 forks source link

STLs not manifold #3

Closed kefir- closed 11 years ago

kefir- commented 11 years ago

Opening 01-pvc_pipe_support_a.stl in slic3r gives a warning about a hole in the mesh. Cleaning it manually in blender, I removed 16 duplicate vertices and one edge that shouldn't have been there (blender highlights it when selecting "Non Manifold" with Shift-Ctrl-Alt-m). After that, slic3r is fine with the part.

I'd be happy to share the fixed part, but if openscad currently generates broken stl from the scad file, then the correct fix probably lies with openscad.

qharley commented 11 years ago

Is this the only part with troubles? I know I had to fix some of the other parts as well, and I tried to only post fixed parts to the git repository.

Definitely some issue with OpenSCAD at the moment. I will look for an update.

Sent from my iPad

On 26 Jun 2013, at 1:27, kefir- notifications@github.com wrote:

Opening 01-pvc_pipe_support_a.stl in slic3r gives a warning about a hole in the mesh. Cleaning it manually in blender, I removed 16 duplicate vertices and one edge that shouldn't have been there (blender highlights it when selecting "Non Manifold" with Shift-Ctrl-Alt-m). After that, slic3r is fine with the part.

I'd be happy to share the fixed part, but if openscad currently generates broken stl from the scad file, then the correct fix probably lies with openscad.

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/qharley/Morgan/issues/3 .

kefir- commented 11 years ago

Not sure, I only opened 01 and 02 in slic3r, and got a warning for 01, which is why I opened it in blender. I can check more after work today.

kefir- commented 11 years ago

Seems I was just unlucky when the first object I tried had issues. All the other ones appear to be ok.

The fixed object is available here:

http://kefirshare.dreamhosters.com/01-pvc_pipe_support_a-fixed.stl

qharley commented 11 years ago

Thanks,

I "fixed" all the others again this afternoon, and found some smaller issues on them, but nothing serious. I'll try them out before pushing to git just in case of fixed something too aggressively...

Cheers, Quentin

On Wed, Jun 26, 2013 at 7:31 PM, kefir- notifications@github.com wrote:

Seems I was just unlucky when the first object I tried had issues. All the other ones appear to be ok.

The fixed object is available here:

http://kefirshare.dreamhosters.com/01-pvc_pipe_support_a-fixed.stl

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/qharley/Morgan/issues/3#issuecomment-20065536 .