Closed fbricon closed 1 month ago
/cc @aloubyansky (extension-proposal), @gastaldi (extension-proposal), @gsmet (extension-proposal), @maxandersen (extension-proposal,jbang), @quarkusio/devtools (jbang)
As discussed on Zulip there was some concern about jmDNS being Apache 2.0 licensed. It has some LGPL sample code but not in the library itself. The history of the license and how it was transferred is here: https://github.com/jmdns/jmdns/blob/main/NOTICE.txt
Essentially the original authors gave permission to move it to Apache 2.0 instead of LGPL or dual licensed.
Java Multicast Domain Name Server (JmDNS)
This project was originally developed by Arthur van Hoff under the GNU Lesser General Public License as jRendevous. It was moved to Sourceforge by Rick Blair and renamed to JmDNS with the Arthur's kind permission. It has been re-released under the Apache License, Version 2.0. In 2014, it has been moved from Sourceforge to Github by Kai Kreuzer with the kind approval from Arthur and Rick.
The real issue with forking is the library uses javax.jmdns
is in packaging. It has for 21 years but this will cause Quarkus classloading issues.
We asked the developer about changing the packaging: https://github.com/jmdns/jmdns/issues/289
Developer response:
If Oracle themself is not permitting us the continued use (with really only patching a decades old library) and reaches out to us directly, I am willing to create a new major release of JmDNS with a changed namespace, which is not backward compatible and breaks everyone's code. Until then, I reject this issue for the best interest of our users.
Description
Inspired by https://www.localcan.com/, I've been playing with a PoC to automatically register an
<application>.local
domain when running in dev mode. It uses mDNS to generate .local domain names. This JBang-based PoC is available at https://gist.github.com/fbricon/cf25b6670659216447e17712d5acd7f6#file-qmdns-java-L60-L97You can run it with JBang, as in
(trust the url) then
I and other people think it might be worth making a quarkus-mdns extension out of it, usable when running in Dev mode.
Interested in this extension, please +1 via the emoji/reaction feature of GitHub (top right).
Repository name
quarkus-mdns
Short description
Automatically register an
<application>.local
domain when running Quarkus dev modeRepository Homepage URL
https://quarkiverse.github.io/quarkiverse-docs/quarkus-mdns/dev/
Repository Topics
Team Members
Additional context
No response