Closed mabijkerk closed 1 year ago
We have been asked to write queries for the number of units of heat pumps. When I query all the heat pumps in the application group, I will for example get households_space_heater_heatpump_air_water_electricity
and the households_water_heater_heatpump_air_water_electricity
.
I would assume that they represent the same technology, and that households_cooling_heatpump_air_water_electricity
should be counted as the same single technology as well. However, when I query the NoU, i get different results for each technology:
EACH(
V(households_space_heater_heatpump_air_water_electricity,number_of_units),
V(households_water_heater_heatpump_air_water_electricity,number_of_units),
V(households_cooling_heatpump_air_water_electricity,number_of_units)
)
[
189,434.8567100454,
150,336.209112773,
55,453.84958161603,
]
@redekok do you happen to know more about this topic? How should the NoU be interpreted? Because the heating and cooling sliders are not linked, I can understand why the NoU for heating and cooling do not align by default. However, for space and water heating I would conceptually expect them to produce the same result.
I think the NoU are derived from the (peak?) demand and the heat capacity per unit. Perhaps you could compare the ratio between the (peak) heat demand of both nodes to the ratio between the NoU to check if this is indeed the case?
Thanks for this @redekok, I agree that this is how it functions technically. For me the issue is more conceptually: is communicating the number of units for each technology actually what ENTSO want to know?
From the discussion we just had I think it would be good to check with the client how they want to use these new queries. Then we can decide whether the number of units attribute serves their needs, or whether we should consider implementing a different kind of query:
I just had short discussion with the client. We agreed that I will deliver the queries as is i.e., querying the number_of_units
attribute. We then do need to clearly communicate how the number_of_units
should be interpreted. This can be included in the Excel in which I track all the query requests.
As requested by ENTSO, the following selection of queries should be added to the model.
Agreed selection:
Process:
Questions:
Should water and space heaters be counted as a single unit?Should cooling and heating be counted as a single unit?What type of unit isindustry_chemicals_other_steam_recompression_electricity
(should it be added to list of heat pumps)Can COP be queried from all heat pumps?