quiqueck / BetterNether

BetterNether Mod
https://modrinth.com/mod/betternether
Other
20 stars 27 forks source link

[Suggestion] Recipe Handling #109

Closed Parkanizor closed 1 year ago

Parkanizor commented 1 year ago

Description

Please consider using normal json data files for recipes, instead of the current java injection method. I don't know why recipes are insisted on being handled this way, when it has caused dozens of issue posts for modpack authors trying to work around it.

I'm told to use the recipes.json config to remove them, but the file is missing a lot of the mod's recipes. Many of the recipes I'd like to change (soups, ruby tools, etc.) aren't even in there.

Then I'm told to use items.json and blocks.json to remove the items, but touching those configs in any way crashes the game instantly, as many issue posts and confused Discord messages constantly mention. Recently I've seen the author say to not touch those configs at all on 1.19, so what am I supposed to do?

These issues don't exist with other mods. I've spent 30+ hours trying to configure BetterEnd and BetterNether, trying to use all sorts of workarounds just to configure them. I myself am willing to convert the recipes into standard datapack json format and send it your way, if this is something that would be helpful.

Parkanizor commented 1 year ago

Y'know I realize this was kind of unprofessional and not very constructive. Apologies, this was probably not something that should have been posted to Github. Thank you for the continued support for the mod. If you ever do want to switch to json recipe files, I would still be happy to put together a datapack.