quran / quran_android

a quran reading application for android
http://android.quran.com
GNU General Public License v3.0
2k stars 886 forks source link

am i allowed to upload this project to my playstore account ? #839

Closed stickylabdev closed 7 years ago

stickylabdev commented 7 years ago

am i allowed

ozbek commented 7 years ago

Why would you want to do that?

stickylabdev commented 7 years ago

i want to join all feature include as sunnah and al qur an

nyitgroup commented 7 years ago

People ask for that but I think it is better to work together and improve one app.

ozbek commented 7 years ago

i want to join all feature include as sunnah and al qur an

Yes, you can make modifications, build a new app and publish in Play Store. However,

stickylabdev commented 7 years ago

but , am i allowed to monetize the modificated source then the earning i will donate to suriah , idlib and other country that need help

nyitgroup commented 7 years ago

According to the License https://github.com/quran/quran_android/blob/master/LICENSE You can use the code for commercial gain. The question is how are you going to do it. Some people just put ads everywhere which would not be nice.

Abdullah076 commented 7 years ago

ads are annoying & disturbing for islamic apps. many times a improper picture of non-mahram woman may appear in ad; which is not at all expected by islamic app users specially in Quran app. so I am strongly agianst ads. if someone want to monetize, he can make the app paid. or make option to donate if any one wants to. but not by ads!

nyitgroup commented 7 years ago

That is interesting. Why isn't there a donation button on the current app? We can call it buy coffee for the developers? 5$ You guys work hard. I would not mind donating.

stickylabdev commented 7 years ago

maybe i will block the porn ads sources ,but let me add the ads outside the main quran ,

ahmedre commented 7 years ago

@muafakul:

please don't do this -

  1. this is disrespectful to the book of Allah
  2. you are profiting off the efforts and work of many people who put hard work and effort to provide this app to people for free. this is not right morally or otherwise. we open sourced this app so people can contribute code or learn how to do things in their own apps, not so they can profit off of our work.
  3. there is an ongoing cost to maintaining this app (servers cost money every month, and pages and audio download from our servers).
  4. the materials we use (pages, audio, translations, etc) have licenses - most people don't mind using their data in a free app, but would be unhappy about profiting from their efforts and work.

if you want to use ads, please write your own app without using any of our code or content.

Abdullah076 commented 7 years ago

even if you block porn ads; there is chance that images of non-mahram may appear. cause for muslims we have to lower our gaze. it includes women who may not be in improper dress; but her hair/face is open. i dont think there will be any way to block all woman (i dont mean porn; i mean every improper/proper woman without hijab). that is unexpected by islamic app users. they dont use islamic apps to do zina of eyes, right?

Abdullah076 commented 7 years ago

brother, ahmed i recently wanted to donate on your Quran project. but the donation is showing that you dont accept donations. can you tell me how can i donate in your app?

ahmedre commented 7 years ago

jazakAllah khairan @Abdullah076 - we don't have a donation option right now, most importantly, please keep us in your du3a insha'Allah :)

ahmedre commented 7 years ago

closing, please re-open if necessary

thawri1 commented 1 year ago

excuse me for reopening. @ahmedre I am hired to develop a Quran app in a specific language. I am working on it from scratch and different UI. this app will be free and without ads inshallah. can I use some portion of the codes or some classes (for example QuranInfo, QuranDataSource, MadaniDataSource, etc)? can I use databases and other data? if I use them, must open source all codes? I don't know much about licenses and my boss does not like to open source the project.