installation via OCICL

[MarcRohrer]

Hi,

I tried to installed CLOG on Windows via OCICL, but:

H:\src>mkdir clog

H:\src>cd clog

H:\src\clog>ocicl install clog
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/clog@sha256:9f3415c31dac331b896b4fb06f7c640ce5bfea69d4d2ac7e0f45876945644732
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/clack@sha256:74657e323ad402af72f5eb2b668035539f687502606c47b880f76f9b38d7d325
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/lack@sha256:1224e0d4ecb16655b8b2f2469aa04cc6e0a8db533cbc654bd07b7c5856da8d6e
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/ironclad@sha256:06ecd2ec5c41c61cce6788adde6a8e56b6002764042002d9ff13308c998fffdd
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/bordeaux-threads@sha256:9df017ccbb783949cdaea6c7849d678105e041b784d0fc738220873739c3bfe5
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/alexandria@sha256:2204779a9711f65532863abc61e9644c2a5a6839c4544516f19d04b699af8a7a
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/global-vars@sha256:22937c8bd0f635855c2c044b0ae0ab3b438ba5e858192dae462807148547d99a
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/trivial-features@sha256:9da86d54aeabcaeb43e69e0a1d6d04c42d9446f2094c8752d89d4ca6ba1b7cbd
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/trivial-garbage@sha256:fdcc5b6acd3eacb1e9ee305685b72ea270435cf363ea7a9cb1cc3d86a3534ed7
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/usocket@sha256:e8f5862adc7ac2a5e9d25cf01e63cdffde2a1c553379d91aa2ad3dad0ad3c491
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/split-sequence@sha256:e3883aa62ed7def931505d24f3cde4ab47d4a715cebf32de90615b8dad292bac
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/swank@sha256:a280fabc40b8394ab39562846887a335a165118e7765b6721e1b74529791630f
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/websocket-driver@sha256:ce9e8e42c375b013d6ed18b15f20c2b53fd91683f9548165814cb385de7978fd
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/fast-websocket@sha256:0bdb0f14542d60ab48f435abb5f39a858de4b7285b1209871dbdff7227727977
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/fast-io@sha256:d5907b55d2d46cfe6a811e560faf487b6cdf150c0074fe3557438a2143744998
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/trivial-gray-streams@sha256:e732a802d3207ac012d4ffdcf18f3a2bcbf2e625c00b6a90ca5ea861c858bb32
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/static-vectors@sha256:54e113712b9f3ca0c5809b6769812bfda1a59cc3094575385856a17c5c2eb246
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/cffi@sha256:b6f93e6cfd73fb3e9dd33474fb81760a5fe3617cc32cff8811d8a3e3769a360d
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/babel@sha256:beda9fd8bec204f077596f8d91b819dba31444dfec7a670575ca6055a9dbfabb
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/event-emitter@sha256:888209116a90ef9a97c4d401e94428e798da3daf7d30d7d0d6d8ac32624fe87a
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/sha1@sha256:4ee91733ee872864c804d29dbdf417b7fbacf489e8c5e71f047f76499777adb7
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/cl-base64@sha256:a88846138b190a3a4a7082e44f360236faccb9f545cd38b7b12ae07eae292e3d
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/cl_plus_ssl@sha256:28052d1112e5d42d38ea01cda70cfa122bc361dedd720d8fdb5cd409e0e41459
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/flexi-streams@sha256:2eb7271c30799a51bb3720ca37ee358764522255d66aabcc1a3012becfab1dbc
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/fast-http@sha256:1f2532bd45c68ed5ff7e7f2876c59c823aeff31044826b055a46ffa18752cdc6
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/cl-utilities@sha256:e3f78ec41bc5024050c11772fcfb6b773eade4c002b9260a7d16a76d098cea42
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/proc-parse@sha256:19dad8a437f8885b91a5939aef5ea691aa19225eaf3ad4616e58d3898dd12a5d
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/xsubseq@sha256:bd2fd7822275156ad788c6e3d67b519f69b85fcc800fe5798184281cd127e45a
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/smart-buffer@sha256:0a6e068b34b9be33f3a3c996cf31453ac68acd82b7deff7c4827e8fc6b4cd18d
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/quri@sha256:3d3c62bb4e3da80c7d9c6829010e0f4a223ab3fe13b31dd1821b352f04d24909
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/hunchentoot@sha256:50dd44b1aa49c24047bb86271238ee816c3b65d45589b9e90c9dfb26f28eae11
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/chunga@sha256:5f99909890ba5bf2a725e6de75baab3fff3750d4bf2818f9f0b46c4eeed98703
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/cl-fad@sha256:4abd6537a2e7115b20dbe46c7e6656923f42686d78820d42ed54d6833b6410fc
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/cl-ppcre@sha256:da286c491967b814862b089d16f51d54ed6412e51f4fccb5a479cef5f41a1849
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/md5@sha256:00e8b92eea99b82a75eac0e359316bdd532f3aa076a24ba27e8e1958790c5447
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/rfc2388@sha256:6fe862d7c4bb7553b9a4372c5ca97cba2c2582c134aef921f9434db5b0cc024c
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/trivial-backtrace@sha256:8189c3a641490b523a67b6711bdf44a2b4b64e2c51604cf991247d9353597d21
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/trivial-open-browser@sha256:47f53f7a4d0a94292570a1f777fd8437e1ae7a173f8e43469f625f877f289622
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/parse-float@sha256:ac97572fb76ce4512e43399ac40f8c7f56e75bcd86e2eb080d3cc501fe22e17c
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/trivial-mimes@sha256:5b7f32f90f94fb73cde2e7d1f2a941fe5ee1a3d22b316e6837303e6efe07a28a
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/trivial-rfc-1123@sha256:0c3d00e8cd13b7c325fcff3a1ed912a60c7a3ee8f06f94265e4d01a2a0b72278
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/http-body@sha256:6cf92164a536aed3a16b532d067b47f2bf9dc57751b82a690dbd79e9598e967e
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/jonathan@sha256:1ba63deac3ec7b9c7b51b8610d731922534463e641659c28eb0568ee59e76d43
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/cl-syntax@sha256:980cfae2c3e546b18199849b39f922134b6053b4455ee3804d8cc49f92021bbd
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/trivial-types@sha256:441b53889ea0479df78424dca18172d4a67f7c816b56163c884e1e0bc74be4d7
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/named-readtables@sha256:c13ae35d957cf55f8c877762a24537daee5e8322d9968b14f8c86e8cfc1b2df3
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/cl-annot@sha256:611a41daa8943d3a6c29c21b1ebf8459d70fc69ccc73203b6fa58bf333901bed
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/circular-streams@sha256:1ed2c55b357f47a92d43e8158615f7220f0998cac73c729b63b4d6a4b480923b
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/closer-mop@sha256:41002bac33411683ab917153091aa9bea7c01a6abf9b869252e89d64f36a4546
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/mgl-pax@sha256:3a5c4c409f126728c09156fd6eafaa3a80aa1804d82fe777937f7ab72e3e13cb
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/pythonic-string-reader@sha256:a4474310196c2f3e724f42f90ffe15387b03d587e7b4e224e2873d8f321136b3
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/cl-template@sha256:2996b5710a1bc413902fc3f4026aad051e40472f24e929feb058d2454059d650
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/atomics@sha256:7e8c10a6aa9c075752458084e77ace432808ac144429c8e862a0b049639c5efc
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/documentation-utils@sha256:b2a1b3f3bcd1a738af85ae2b0168d408c177661eab6d6bbebb254e394d983f54
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/trivial-indent@sha256:6fe5b8470816a715113c0f123d41d52fc2782309fd5fc33a494dd887c6c677ce
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/sqlite@sha256:2742f8c3ff9fb2bf463fe176da1dab28106b030a3f15fb4b79d2dd5891b0b89e
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/iterate@sha256:b605c6d0144892db02c4fc50094b4f854813b0daac54c840f15ba0e921283851
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/cl-dbi@sha256:eec4b0ac8b794db6e51ae034008e667e577c88278ee104eab1a8cfdfc01b5c0b
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/cl-pass@sha256:1b407ad304da67555a83d7f0a81e0f7528c9e31b39fbaa0839080357ab30c489
; downloaded ghcr.io/ocicl/trivial-utf-8@sha256:6ad4c3d48f37cc4eb7a1af18399e8d3f3c506b682ab9498c93130dd3dae1ce1c
;
; caught ERROR:
;   READ error during COMPILE-FILE:
;
;     Package CL-ISAAC does not exist.
;
;       Line: 98, Column: 22, File-Position: 3853
;
;       Stream: #<SB-INT:FORM-TRACKING-STREAM for "file H:\\src\\clog\\systems\\lack-20240202-c09ef66\\src\\util.lisp" {100440D153}>

debugger invoked on a UIOP/LISP-BUILD:COMPILE-FILE-ERROR in thread
#<THREAD "main thread" RUNNING {10013C0073}>:
  COMPILE-FILE-ERROR while compiling #<CL-SOURCE-FILE "lack-util" "src/util">

Type HELP for debugger help, or (SB-EXT:EXIT) to exit from SBCL.

restarts (invokable by number or by possibly-abbreviated name):
  0: [RETRY                        ] Retry
                                     compiling #<CL-SOURCE-FILE "lack-util" "src/util">.
  1: [ACCEPT                       ] Continue, treating
                                     compiling #<CL-SOURCE-FILE "lack-util" "src/util">
                                     as having been successful.
  2:                                 Retry ASDF operation.
  3: [CLEAR-CONFIGURATION-AND-RETRY] Retry ASDF operation after resetting the
                                     configuration.
  4:                                 Retry ASDF operation.
  5:                                 Retry ASDF operation after resetting the
                                     configuration.
  6: [ABORT                        ] Exit from the current thread.

(UIOP/LISP-BUILD:CHECK-LISP-COMPILE-RESULTS NIL T T "~/asdf-action::format-action/" ((#<ASDF/LISP-ACTION:COMPILE-OP > . #<ASDF/LISP-ACTION:CL-SOURCE-FILE "lack-util" "src/util">)))
   error finding frame source: Bogus form-number: the source file has probably
                               changed too much to cope with.
   source: NIL
0]

The OCICL maintainer Anthony Green says:

This is a bug in lack-util. cl-isaac is not supported on Windows, and yet the cl-isaac package is referenced unconditionally in lack-util.

defsystem "lack-util"
  :version "0.2.0"
  :author "Eitaro Fukamachi"
  :license "MIT"
  :depends-on ((:feature (:or :windows :mswindows :win32 :cormanlisp) "ironclad")
               (:feature (:not (:or :windows :mswindows :win32 :cormanlisp)) "cl-isaac")
               "bordeaux-threads")
  :components ((:file "src/util"))
  :in-order-to ((test-op (test-op "t-lack-util"))))

But then in util.lisp:

;; Patch to fix bug in cl-isaac.
;; When PR is accepted in cl-isaac, the code below can be removed

(defun cl-isaac:rand32 (ctx)
  ;;(declare (optimize (speed 3) (safety 0)))
  (cond
    ((zerop (cl-isaac::isaac-ctx-randcnt ctx))
     (cl-isaac::generate-next-isaac-block ctx)
     (setf (cl-isaac::isaac-ctx-randcnt ctx) 255)
     (aref (cl-isaac::isaac-ctx-randrsl ctx) 255))
    (t
     (aref (cl-isaac::isaac-ctx-randrsl ctx)
           (decf (cl-isaac::isaac-ctx-randcnt ctx))))))

Marc Rohrer

[rabbibotton]

when I manually build on windows from command line I just quickload cl-isaac and then after build clog, it seems to work in slime likely already loaded there, happy you found the cause. Let me know when your fix is included in lack and will remove from my clogez-win64 distro of clog

[MarcRohrer]

Sorry, misunderstanding here! I have no association with any of the libraries you use! I just wanted to let you know, that there is a problem.

[rabbibotton]

I know :) I happen to have run into this many times and am really happy to understand why now and why my work around to pre-load cl-isaac needed.

On Sun, Apr 21, 2024 at 1:28 PM Marc Rohrer @.***> wrote:

Sorry, misunderstanding here! I have no association with any of the libraries you use! I just wanted to let you know, that there is a problem.

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/rabbibotton/clog/issues/343#issuecomment-2068142059, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ACYUEFMUQ3XVWZCCT4LDVJ3Y6PZM7AVCNFSM6AAAAABGRQABZKVHI2DSMVQWIX3LMV43OSLTON2WKQ3PNVWWK3TUHMZDANRYGE2DEMBVHE . You are receiving this because you commented.Message ID: @.***>

[MarcRohrer]

Perfect!So probably the best approach would be, you contact the creator of that library 🌝I do not even know what it is all about 😳

[rabbibotton]

https://github.com/fukamachi/lack/issues/83

lol thought that was yours :) someone already added it and I subscribed to issue and gave same work around for now.

[MarcRohrer]

🌝