search

ramprs / grad-cam

[ICCV 2017] Torch code for Grad-CAM
https://arxiv.org/abs/1610.02391
1.48k stars 224 forks source link

The results are differenct from Grad_CAM paper and Web_Demo. #1

Closed gaobb closed 7 years ago

gaobb commented 7 years ago

This is a very interesting work! Thanks for your share. I found that there is a bit difference between your paper's result and web_demo's for cat visualization. The guided_cam result based on web_demo have some noises for "cat" (e.g., part of dog head).! web_demo result paper reult I also reproduce the Grad_CAM experiments with MatConvNet. But my result is similar to your web_demo. I want to know that how to produce the paper's result.

screenshot from 2016-10-29 12 53 38 screenshot from 2016-10-29 12 54 18

abhshkdz commented 7 years ago

Hi @gaobb, yeah, we're aware of it. The code and web demo are accurate. We'll update the paper figure, an rgb transpose bug crept through there :(

abhshkdz commented 7 years ago

The images in the repository readme are accurate though. Your matconvnet results look good!

gaobb commented 7 years ago

Thanks for your quick and effective reply.

xiahuaxiebangmianjinpao commented 5 years ago

I want to reproduce the Grad_CAM experiments with MatConvNet,can you send me your code with MatConvNet?

xiahuaxiebangmianjinpao commented 5 years ago

@gaobb I want to reproduce the Grad_CAM experiments with MatConvNet,can you send me your code with MatConvNet?Thank you very much!