search

raoergsls / miranda

Automatically exported from code.google.com/p/miranda
0 stars 1 forks source link

Delivery reports problem with Trillian on Jabber (scriver_64) #1750

Open GoogleCodeExporter opened 9 years ago

GoogleCodeExporter commented 9 years ago 
Miranda Version                  : v0.10.21.0 x64 (Built Jan 15 2014 17:37:36)
Unicode Build                    : Yes

What steps will reproduce the problem?
1. download and unzip miranda-im-v0.10.21-x64.7z
2. download and install plugin scriver.dll from 
miranda-im-v0.10.21-x64-contrib.7z
3. run Miranda, create profile, add jabber account, connect to network
4. in "Options -> Network -> <jabber account> -> Advanced" change (tick) option 
"Send messages slower, but with full acknowledgement" (under "Miscellaneous -> 
Messaging")
5. send message to some jabber contact using desktop Trillian

What is the expected result?
 - Message is sent to the contact, added to history and displayed in chat log

What happens instead?
 - message is delivered to the contact, but not added into local history and chat log
 - error appears: The message send timed out. (see screenshot)

VersionInfo and network log is attached.

Same error with several different sending accounts from Miranda and with 
several different receiving accounts on Trillian. Captured test is performed 
against account gury@jabber.cz, resource GURY-PC, software Trillian, version 
5.4.0.15.

It seems to be working as expected on 32 bit build (with 32 bit scriver) and 
also with any other accounts using non-Trillian software. Also with Trillian on 
iPhone (version 2.1.0.9d) it is working well.

The only information related to this issue I have found on internet is bug 
report on Miranda-ng:
http://trac.miranda-ng.org/ticket/457
I've also asked on forum:
http://forums.miranda-im.org/showthread.php?29193-Delivery-reports-problem-with-
Trillian-on-Jabber
but with no replay.

Is this issue a bug? Is it a bug of Miranda? Or of Trillian? Did anybody came 
across this issue in the past?

Thanks for replay and possible for patching it.
Fosfor

Original issue reported on code.google.com by fosfor.s...@seznam.cz on 16 Feb 2014 at 3:39

Attachments:

GoogleCodeExporter commented 9 years ago 
The tocket on Miranda NG bug tracker makes it quite clear:

>it's a well known problem with the Trillian's stupidity. Trillian declares 
that it's able to deal with chat states, but fails to support the message 
delivery.
>it's definitely not a problem of Miranda.

The bug is definately NOT on Miranda side, but on Trillian side

Original comment by wishmaster51 on 16 Feb 2014 at 4:53

GoogleCodeExporter commented 9 years ago 
You can try a workaround: Set in database editor the setting <proto>/MsgAck to 
0. This disables message delivery notification for the specific contact.

Original comment by wishmaster51 on 16 Feb 2014 at 5:37

GoogleCodeExporter commented 9 years ago 
Hi and sorry for a late answer - I had tested to disable message delivery 
notifications and because it was working I've completely forget about this 
issue;) So:

As I didn’t find DB editor for my 64bit version, I tried to disable delivery 
notification for whole jabber ("Send messages slower, but with full 
acknowledgement" off) and then this issue disappeared. Drawback is that you are 
not aware of real undelivered messages.

Was this issue somehow discussed with Trillian? With what result?

In case it was not discussed - please help me clarify the problem (I'll try on 
my own with Trillian developers):

According to the log - Trillian client declares to handle jabber:x:event 
feature (which is obsoleted for more than 3 years, but client does not declares 
to handle a "new" urn:xmpp:receipts), but when my client sends a message with 
<x xmlns="jabber:x:event"><delivered/><offline/></x> it gets no answer - which 
is a problem, because it should (if the message itself is delivered/stored for 
offline delivery). And this is a problem of the Trillian client, which should 
replay to this request. Am I right?

BTW: it has no connection with “chat states” (XEP-0085) as this doesn't 
handle per-message event itself - OK?

Original comment by fosfor.s...@seznam.cz on 5 Dec 2014 at 11:49

GoogleCodeExporter commented 9 years ago 
No one will answer you here. All Miranda IM devs are gone. If you can, switch 
to Miranda NG :-)

And I think you should discuss it with Trillian yourself, surely no one else 
from here did.

Original comment by ROBYER on 6 Dec 2014 at 6:46