search

rapideditor / temaki

🐡 An icon expansion pack for Maki
https://rapideditor.github.io/temaki/docs
Other
78 stars 22 forks source link

Create fire_hydrant_underground.svg #91

Closed qugebert closed 8 months ago

qugebert commented 8 months ago

I combined the existing icons from gas_manhole.svg and hydrant.svg and made it oval.

bhousel commented 8 months ago

Thanks! Is this related to some other issue somewhere? Also, why did you make it oval?

qugebert commented 8 months ago

There has been the suggestion to make a seperate preset for underfloor hydrants to avoid confusion (pillar icon might be confusing for underfloor hydrants), somewhere here: https://github.com/streetcomplete/StreetComplete/pull/5373#issuecomment-1864784864

It is oval, because all underfloor hydrant manholes i've ever seen are oval. See for example https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/File:Berlin_hydrant_20050211_p1000517.jpg and the actual pillar is mounted by firefighters if needed: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/File:Standrohr_unterflurhydrant.jpg And in editors where the icons are quite small, the oval form might help to distinguish it as fire hydrant manhole.

But i didn't think that they might look different in other countries, sorry.

qugebert commented 8 months ago

Ok, i tried how it would look in id-editor, the small icons are too small in all cases, but i think the round is a bit better. grafik grafik

bhousel commented 8 months ago

Thanks, yeah I agree that the round one looks a little better. At that small size it's really hard to see the details in either case, but I mostly think it would be weird for this icon to be a different shape from all the other ones.