Closed juju2013 closed 2 years ago
https://www.keil.com/pack/doc/CMSIS/SVD/html/elem_device.html doesn't describe the description
as required. Or does "Occurrence: 1..1" actually mean the same thing as "Use: required"? :thinking:
Actually, looking at the file that you linked to:
<!-- version specifies the version of the device description -->
<xs:element name="version" type="stringType"/>
<!-- description is a string describing the device features (e.g. memory size, peripherals, etc.) -->
<xs:element name="description" type="stringType"/>
<!-- V1.1: licenseText specifies the file header section to be included in any derived file -->
<xs:element name="licenseText" type="stringType" minOccurs="0"/>
where does it say that description
is mandatory? (I'm not being antagonistic, I'm just trying to work out what I've missed)
Not a big fan of XML, so maybe I'm in the wrong, but according to this specification, use
is for attributes and min/maxOccurs
are for elements, and in the latter case, the default value is 1.
Where things become complicated: register name is declared alike while peripheral name explicitly says
My bad, I was looking at minOccurs="1"
- both of them are obviously mandatory ... what's the author's exact intent is not clear for me here.peripheral
s, which is the parent of peripheral
(without s) and the latter is coherent with other type definition.
BTW, it would be nice to have a nice description of this nice device ;)
When passing rp2040.svd w3c's validator, it appears that not only the description field of device is mandatory, but there's also other issues.
So I'll close this issue and open a more generic one.
It looks like there's an error in the rp2040.svd file.
Per specification of CMSIS-SVD (near the text "
description is a string describing the device features (e.g. memory size, peripherals, etc.)
"), the field "description" of element "device" is mandatory.In the actual rp2040.svd, this field is missing.