rcpch / digital-growth-charts-react-component-library

A typescript React library for displaying RCPCH Digital Growth Charts from API data
https://growth.rcpch.ac.uk
MIT License
8 stars 11 forks source link

extended BMI SDS #54

Open eatyourpeas opened 1 year ago

eatyourpeas commented 1 year ago

A suggestion from Mars Skae, endocrinologist is for more SDS lines on the centile charts for children of high BMI She cites the CDC

statist7 commented 1 year ago

The questions to ask are: which extra SDS lines would they be, and in what circumstances would they be drawn?

The current centiles are spaced 2/3 SDS up to 2 2/3, so it would be plausible to continue on that basis with the same spacing, as 3 1/3 and 4 etc. Another alternative would be to space them more widely at say 2 SDS apart, i.e. at 4 and 6 to match 2, which I think would be better. It would be straightforward to interpolate or extrapolate using the +2 and +4 lines.

In terms of drawing the lines, it would be good to develop an algorithm which drew them when required and not otherwise. This would avoid having to customise the chart. Perhaps when the BMI SDS is sufficiently far above the 99.6th centile it triggers the +4 or even the +6 line being plotted.

dc2007git commented 9 months ago

@eatyourpeas is this issue still open for discussion?

eatyourpeas commented 3 months ago

Discussion at Project Board 22.8.24 BMI charts should have SDS lines at: