readthedocs / website

The Read the Docs community website
15 stars 5 forks source link

Update About page -> How it works #174

Closed ericholscher closed 1 year ago

ericholscher commented 1 year ago

This makes it a bit more obvious what the page is about, and isn't confused with the About us page.

Already put in a redirect:

Screenshot 2022-11-25 at 9 07 42 AM

:books: Documentation preview :books:: https://read-the-docs-site-community--174.com.readthedocs.build/en/174/

ericholscher commented 1 year ago

@agjohnson I'm confused, since you suggested the exact opposite on Slack: https://readthedocs.slack.com/archives/C1VM2ENUB/p1668462658520369 -- I originally suggested Product Overview, which I think is the right framing.

I'd just like to get this change out since the current implementation is confusing, so are you 👍 with Overview and we can iterate on a larger menu later?

agjohnson commented 1 year ago

My suggestion in that conversation was to put verbose options in a dropdown menu, which is in line with my suggestion above. Guessing this is missing from the context, as I thought you agreed with my suggestion for the dropdown in that conversation :shrug:

so are you +1 with Overview and we can iterate on a larger menu later?

I mean, I don't share the priority on renaming the about page, so no. I would replace the top navigation with a dropdown first, which is what I described in that conversation:

https://readthedocs.slack.com/archives/C1VM2ENUB/p1668462728477219

Thinking farther ahead, "Overview" is okay title for the about page, but I wouldn't reuse "Overview" for a dropdown later. So this would be a bad half-step. As a navigation link to a page, "Product" is horribly unclear -- it doesn't describe what to expect at all. But, as a dropdown, "Product" works better than other options, as these page links will be verbose submenu entries inside the dropdown anyways.

So to clarify, I would:

If you feel like managing this change and redirects twice, you can rename "about" to "product". Without the dropdown, this is a lateral move though, and doesn't seem any clearer. So seems like wasted effort.

ericholscher commented 1 year ago

OK. I will close this then, and wait for you to do a dropdown 👍