rebipp / ppi

REBIPP: Plant-Pollinator Interactions Data Vocabulary
https://ppi.rebipp.org.br
GNU General Public License v3.0
30 stars 5 forks source link

availableFlowerQuantity #40

Closed zedomel closed 3 years ago

zedomel commented 3 years ago
Field Value
GUID
Rebipp Class rebipp:PlantTrait
Label availableFlowerQuantity
Definition The number or enumeration value for the quantity of open flowers or inflorescences available to visitors.
Comments
Examples 0, 30, 40
Controlled vocabulary
Darwin Core Class Occurrence
Cardinality One to one
Reference Protocol
zedomel commented 3 years ago

Change term definition: The quantity of open flowers or inflorescences available to floral visitors

Do we really need the available to floral visitors in the term definition? How can an open flower not be available?

fonturbel commented 3 years ago

Indeed, this term could be simply called "flowerQuantity"

Andre-Luis-Acosta commented 3 years ago

About the quote "How can an open flower not be available?" The term OPEN (potentially) suggests availability .. but, pre-anthesis flowers are present in the plant as well, but they are not available, except for bees like Bombus, which can make a hole at the base of the corolla and extract pollen from closed flowers, but this is stealing (negative interaction for plant). OpenFlowerQuantity?

zedomel commented 3 years ago

@Andre-Luis-Acosta so, we just have to change the definition to avoid ambiguity on the meaning of available. Maybe the definition can be simple like: The quantity of open flowers or inflorescences of an individual plant, so does not matter if it is available or not, since it is open it is potentially available (?)

Sounds better?

carmensspires commented 3 years ago

What do we mean by availableFlowerQuantity? Flowers available to floral visitors? That is, flowers that are open and offering some kind of resource. But, an open flower can be a less attractive flower or even unattractive for the floral visitor. Flowers that have already been pollinated and remain open are less attractive and are available.

I don't see much sense in this label. I think this measure only makes sense if it is associated with the age of the flower and the fact that it is pollinated or not.

When we measure flowers available to pollinators, we count only flowers open on the day of sampling, that is, flowers that will still be visited on that specific day. And the measurements are made depending on the flower's phenology.

But, I leave the decision to the experts in floral biology ....

zedomel commented 3 years ago

@carmensspires your comment shows how ambiguity this term is. We have to define what we mean by available.

Regarding to the associated terms (age of the flower and if it is pollinated or not) I'm not sure how difficult can be to measured that, specially if a flower was pollinated or not. Let's see what other have to say.

The new definition that I proposed in my previous comment sounds more like flowerAbundance: the number of open flowers of an individual. But it may be expressing a different concept compared to the original one (available to floral visitors).

cepnunes commented 3 years ago

Nothing to add.

pjbergamo commented 3 years ago

It is quite impossible to know the age of all flowers or if they were pollinated when one is counting the number of flowers. I see that the problematic word here is 'available'. Therefore, I agree with @zedomel new definition.

viniciusduartina commented 3 years ago

Agree with the new definition. I think we don´t need "available to floral visitors" as well.

carmensspires commented 3 years ago

@zedomel I agree with thew term #flowerAbundance and definition: the number of open flowers of an individual.

anselmoeco commented 3 years ago

I agree with the new term and definition proposed by @zedomel, much better!

Andre-Luis-Acosta commented 3 years ago

@zedomel agree with you on flowerAbundance term

paf1306 commented 3 years ago

Nothing to add.

zedomel commented 3 years ago

New label: flowerAbundance New definition: The number of open flowers of an plant individual