search

redhat-gpe / rhte2018_api_mgmt_and_service_mesh

2 stars 3 forks source link

Can we remove the "Alternatives" section from "API Mgmt and SM Lab?" #39

Closed rdickens-redhat closed 5 years ago

rdickens-redhat commented 6 years ago

Is the "Alternatives" section necessary? If not, I suggest it is deleted.

I understand the benefit to this information, but I don't think it adds value to this lab. The introduction to this paragraph states "...the following are related community initiatives that are not covered in this lab." My reason for suggesting this be deleted from the lab is that presenting information which is not directly relevant to the lab may obscure the information that is relevant.

[1] https://github.com/redhat-gpe/rhte_lab_04_api_mgmt_and_service_mesh/blob/master/modules/01_api_mgmt_service_mesh/01_2_api_mgmt_service_mesh_Lab.adoc#alternatives

jbride commented 5 years ago

Yes, the content found in that section is based on numerous questions asked by students who conducted this lab in previous instructor led trainings.

rdickens-redhat commented 5 years ago

Thanks Jeff. Could we perhaps make it an appendix, and refer to it in the Overview? If students have asked for this information then it should definitely remain. My view is that since 3scale is the focus of this lab, it's potentially distracting to mention alternative technologies in the introduction. I am very new to this topic, though, so if the alternatives should be mentioned here for the benefit of students, please say so.