reichlab / variant-nowcast-hub

A repository to store COVID-19 variant nowcasts collected as a modeling hub.
MIT License
7 stars 4 forks source link

Save a list of state/date combinations not to score for a specific variant-nowcast-hub round #50

Open bsweger opened 1 week ago

bsweger commented 1 week ago

Background

To address the "scoring fairness" modeling challenge identified in the variant-nowcast-hub's README, this hub's evaluation logic will exclude state/date combinations with reported sequence data as of the reference date for a given round that falls into the bounds of the round's target dates.

In other words, any combination of state and target date (where the target date is within 31 days before the Wednesday reference date of the round) that--as of the 8 PM Wednesday submission deadline--has one or more Sars-COV-2 genome sequences with a collection date equal to that target date will not be scored.

Definition of done

bsweger commented 1 week ago

@rogersbw @nickreich @elray1 Feel free to update this if I got the details wrong!

Also, please weigh in on how to format this information for ease of use by the scoring process.

elray1 commented 1 week ago

I made a few updates to clarify that this has to do with combinations of location and date with any reported data by the time of the round closing.

bsweger commented 1 week ago

Copying in clarification from a recent Slack thread:

Q: What did we decide about the evaluation dates - are we going to include in the evaluation ANY location/dates with no counts as of Wednesday night or just the set of location/dates with no data until one is observed? A: any location/dates without observations

bsweger commented 1 week ago

No time travel time required!