rapporteurId is not a document identifier

[ronaldtse]

From: https://github.com/ietf-ribose/relaton-data-3gpp/issues/4

@strogonoff :

Is this an actual document type, like DOI or IEEE?

No. This is wrong. rapporteurId is not a Document Identifier, it is the 3GPP internal ID of the "Rapporteur" of the document (a person).

[ronaldtse]

Maybe this should go into editorial group information? (https://github.com/ietf-ribose/relaton-data-3gpp/issues/5#issuecomment-996381956)

[andrew2net]

@ronaldtse all rapporteurId are integer numbers. I don't think it bears any information to relaton users. Maybe there is a relation to rapporteurs names?

[ronaldtse]

Yes they are related to the names of rapporteurs. Is there a table for rapporteurs?

In any case they are not document identifiers and we should remove from docidentifier

[andrew2net]

@ronaldtse I found only "2003-02-06_spec_level01_table" which has relation with "Specs_GSM+3G" and filed Rapporteur. For example the row form "Specs_GSM+3G":

{:Type=>"TR",
 :Number=>"00.01U"
...

has related row in the "2003-02-06_spec_level01_table":

{:Type=>"TR",
 :Number=>"00.01U",
 :Title=>"Work programme for the standarization of Universal Mobile Telecommunications System (UMTS)",
 :WG=>"-",
 :Rapporteur=>"RAPELI, Juha",
 :general_remarks=>nil,
 :G=>nil,
 :U=>"U",
 :"Spec withdrawn"=>"spec withdrawn",
 :Directory=>"#http://www.3gpp.org/ftp/Specs/archive/00_series/00.01U/#"}

which has :Rapporteur=>"RAPELI, Juha" field. Would it be correct if we add "RAPELI, Juha" to editorial groups?

[ronaldtse]

Actually the temp_status table provides up-to-date information (latest update Oct 2021) regarding:

• rapporteur
• rapporteur organization
• freeze meeting
• WG prime / WG other

Let's use this.

[andrew2net]

Maybe this should go into editorial group information? (ietf-ribose/relaton-data-3gpp#5 (comment))

@ronaldtse maybe rapporteur should go into contributor?

[ronaldtse]

Excellent idea @andrew2net .