search

researchart / fse18

artifacts track, FSE'18: https://2018.fseconference.org/home
2 stars 2 forks source link

Rahman-blizzard #12

Closed obaysal closed 6 years ago

obaysal commented 6 years ago

https://github.com/researchart/fse18/tree/master/submissions/blizzard

anonReviewer commented 6 years ago

This artifact deserves an Available badge. I was able to easily download and run everything as described in the README file, and a DOI is listed and accessible. So I am happy to commend the authors for a very clean and easy-to-use artifact submission.

timm commented 6 years ago

Thank your @anonReviewer for your badging decision. Over to next reviewer

john-james commented 6 years ago

BLIZZARD automatically localizes buggy entities based on source code through query reformulation and information retrieval. In general, BLIZZARD can do the following work: • Getting reformulated queries for a system. • Collecting Top-K bug localization results. • Determining Query Effectiveness (QE) performances. It would be better if the tool could add more parameters to allow better control over the execution of the program (it seems that now all the executions start from the first command). A better UI could be helpful.

I am ok with an Available badge.

timm commented 6 years ago

This concludes this stage of the review process.

masud-technope commented 6 years ago

Thanks to both reviewers for their interesting comments, and a big applause for @obaysal and @timm for this collaborative, active and innovative reviewing system. We will be waiting for the final decision. Cheers!