Closed schrmh closed 1 year ago
Hi,
scrot doesn't do the image encoding itself, it's done via imlib2. imlib2 has loader for jxl but doesn't have a saver yet. You'll have to open an issue on imlib2's repo for it.
Once imlib2 adds a jxl saver, scrot should be able to save jxl files without needing any change. (e.g scrot shot.jxl
will work).
Thanks, any idea why this is under "old" there? »Old code that is mostly for reference/archive purposes«
Edit: Once imlib2 supports saving, would you consider to mention JXL support in the README and the man page? This would give the format some exposure which it deserves IMO.
Currently I convert every new screenshot by using inotify to run a script that converts my PNG screenshots to JXL by making use of cjxl
FYI, you can just use scrot's -e
option (with the $f
specifier) instead of messing with inotify.
any idea why this is under "old" there?
I don't keep up with enlightenment's development, so can't answer that. (But I can tell you that the library is being maintained, in case you're worried about that).
Anyways, closing this since it's out of scrot's control and is an imlib2 issue.
Update: jxl saver was added to imlib2 v1.11.1
. So if you have this version (or later) of imlib2 installed then you can just run scrot shot.jxl
or scrot --format jxl -
to take jxl screenshots.
Caveat: scrot doesn't expose any way to set the "compression" setting for imlib2. So currently all jxl images will just use the default compression level. See https://github.com/resurrecting-open-source-projects/scrot/issues/290.
Thanks, I did not get a notification from the issue from imlib2's repo for some reason so I appreciate the follow up.
It is supported by Qt and GTK, images viewers can display it and GIMP and Krita can edit it. The only missing piece for the GNU/Linux desktop here is the support by screenshot capturing tools.
Currently I convert every new screenshot by using inotify to run a script that converts my PNG screenshots to JXL by making use of cjxl (
cjxl -q 100 -m 1 -e 9 --brotli_effort 11 -E 3 -I 100 -g 3 -j 1
). With that I got JXL files that were about 47% the size the PNG originals had. (I created those PNG files with xfce4-screenshooter before. For PNG images generated by scrot I haven't finished testing yet but could deliver a percentage on a few thousand files tomorrow or so and edit this post then. From the few it converted so far it looks like it's not worse). Edit: for images created by scrot it looks slightly better (but could also be due to switching to cjxl 0.8.1. I used 0.7 before): 44.16% of PNG on average after 3835 images.