Bug: Issue on version 2.4.106 (Wind T-A Alarm) -fixed?

rgleason / watchdog_pi

watchdog plugin for opencpn

GNU General Public License v3.0

1 stars 9 forks source link

Bug: Issue on version 2.4.106 (Wind T-A Alarm) -fixed? #74

Closed Corsair-63 closed 6 months ago

Corsair-63 commented 9 months ago

Windows 11 Pro ARM64 ver 22631.2506 OCPN 5.9.0-0 Watchdog 2.4.101.2

Wind alarm:

still not able to set as True Relative/Absolute
sometimes the layout comes to confusion with the layout of alarm settings with direction/speed. attached screenshot.

Corsair-63 commented 7 months ago

Windows 11 Pro ARM64 ver 22631.2861 OCPN 5.9.0-0+948.1ffe2ef Watchdog 2.4.103

same behaviour with true wind, only followed Apparent.

rgleason commented 7 months ago

Same problem here https://github.com/rgleason/watchdog_pi/issues/88 Failing Alarm: "true Relative Wind" > 9 knots for 1260 seconds (Werner) #88

rgleason commented 6 months ago

@Corsair-63 Carmelo, we really need a VDR file with a ".txt" extension, showing this specific problem. It is necessary to debug and test. Can you upload a file as " ____.txt" using drag and drop to this Issue? Thank you.

Corsair-63 commented 6 months ago

Hi Rick, tested on board and done a VDR file, also, left less NMEA data as possible and only left anemometer, GNSS and auto-pilot.

again, done the same procedure in WD:

tested apparent, working.
True relative, when setup it appears a random value in the speed and I have to exchange to desired alarm value of 25, done, and immediately the alarm triggers as there is no data.
True Absolute, same than above.

not able to set the alarms in any case of True wind, and as you can see there are signal og GNSS and heading device too.

WD_Wind.VDR.txt

rgleason commented 6 months ago

Corsair, please see the new version 2.4.105 pushed to PIM Hopefully this is fixed. We have Dave to thank for spending some time on it.

Corsair-63 commented 6 months ago

for the reason I told I could not deeply test.

now true Relative it seems to work or at least is not giving me error or going to red. true absolute becomes red as soon as activated.

as usual when exchanging from way of measuring relative to true relative either true absolute in the speed alarm setup appear one random number (maybe COG) but it doesn't keep the value of previous alarm.

rgleason commented 6 months ago

We may need to make synthetic files for Wind testing in VDR particularly for Wind True Absolute (Wind T-A)

Example: $xxMWD,302.4,T,289.6,M,10.5,N,5.4,M*6F

For nmea0183 wind sentences Nmea Revealed Simple nmea checksum calculator https://nmeachecksum.eqth.net/

rgleason commented 6 months ago

I've been trying to run this text file to test Wind T-A. It contains all three wind types. Used nmea checksum calculator above.

Wind T-A True Absolute does not seem to be working. If someone has another file that works, turning off and on the alert, please upload. Thanks.

WD_Wind-T-A.txt Screenshot (1928)

rgleason commented 6 months ago

Closing, there is a duplicate.