riparias / gbif-alert

GBIF Alert is a GBIF occurrence based alert system.
https://gbif-alert-demo.thebinaryforest.net/
MIT License
8 stars 2 forks source link

Make website generic/reusable #182

Closed niconoe closed 1 year ago

niconoe commented 2 years ago

I am wondering if it wouldn't be a good contribution to the broader community to actually make the RIPARIAS Early Warning tool as generic as possible (different species / country of interest).

Concretely, that would mean splitting the repository in two:

Any opinions?

damianooldoni commented 2 years ago

This seems a very interesting idea.

niconoe commented 1 year ago

@timadriaens / @peterdesmet / @LienReyserhove (others welcome too!):

Since you know the potential users much better than me: do you think this idea (promoting an improved version of the RIPARIAS alert tool that can be relatively easily configured and deployed for other regions/species of interest) would generate solid interest in the "invasive community" or not?

Also curious about some details (why/why not, factors that would make that easier, ...)

Thanks!

timadriaens commented 1 year ago

It seems a bit stupid to make such a tool only for the RIPARIAS project area indeed although I can see some advantages as well of keeping the project scope. But if you think about it, would it not make more sense to include such alert possibility as a tool in GBIF altogether? Seems something for an Ebbe Nielsen challenge...

timadriaens commented 1 year ago

solid interest in a generic tool: potentially yes. Many people however kind of "distrust" gbif as a data source and put it away as a "poubelle" of many types of data with heterogeneous quality (we have to acknowledge that we are spoiled in that respect in Belgium).

the alert tool now only allows you to select datasets (which is good). If you make a generic one, you probably can use all the filtering options already available within GBIF (e.g. basis of record etc.).

one other thought: such a generic gbif tool might function more as a "publication of data-early warning".

peterdesmet commented 1 year ago

Tim answered this better than I could. Could be a useful Ebbe Nielsen though.

niconoe commented 1 year ago

FYI, I've started ground work for this (I plan to achieve this incrementally, while working in parallel on other features). For now the main concrete tasks are:

damianooldoni commented 1 year ago

Thanks @niconoe to inform me about progress on this work. Yes, I agree to do this in parallel to other tasks as indeed discussed earlier.

You can continue to update me about this work in this issue. Maybe you can create a checklist if you already know more or less the steps?

niconoe commented 1 year ago

Long done!