riparias / gbif-alert

GBIF Alert is a GBIF occurrence based alert system.
https://gbif-alert-demo.thebinaryforest.net/
MIT License
8 stars 2 forks source link

Add new user preference: species name #221

Closed niconoe closed 1 year ago

niconoe commented 1 year ago

This is somewhat similar to #220, please read this first.

We'll soon have 4 names for each species: scientific name + vernacular names in 3 languages. It becomes more and more difficult to decide what we should show to the user.

Therefore, I am wondering if we shouldn't ask users in their registration/profile if they prefer scientific or vernacular names, and respect their choice in the web pages / emails (the other name would still be accessible less directly, for example by hovering the displayed name).

Would that be a good idea?

damianooldoni commented 1 year ago

Very pertinent question. Up to now we tried to avoid such issue by showing only EN vernacular names in species list. However, we knew this solution was a valid although temporary solution (= good for v1).

Here my two cents:

I think in this way we avoid an extra option in the sign up/My profile page which could be quite confusing as we already ask the users to set their preferred language.

The only case my solution will not work is when a user wants to see vernacular names in different language than the language used to show all the rest. Quite a strange wish isn't?

niconoe commented 1 year ago

Yep, that's fine for me! So, let's not add this preference for now, just do smaller changes so both names (scientific + vernacular in selected language) are shown everywhere, without too much overlap / heavy screens.

damianooldoni commented 1 year ago

Yes, let's start with the most reasonable (and feasible) option. I have a meeting on Thursday with some LIFE RIPARIAS users to give them an update about the progress done and plans for the short/long term. I will mention the language aspects of course. I will translate their useful feedback in specific comments on Github issues. Keep posted 👍