Change autograph collections 593 and remove 700

xhero commented 6 years ago

From @lpugin on January 12, 2018 8:49

For collections with a composer where all the items are "Autograph manuscript" in 593 $a:

Change the 593 $a of the collection to "Autograph manuscript"
Remove the 700 where the person is the same as the composer and relator code is "Schreiber" Example: http://www.rism-ch.org/catalog/400102777, http://www.rism-ch.org/catalog/400107252

Copied from original issue: rism-ch/muscat#548

xhero commented 6 years ago

To get that a collection has only 1 composer I trust the presence of 100? Or we can have the case that the collection has 100 and then sources by different composers? When I open the single items, should I consider also the ones that are only "Autograph"?

xhero commented 6 years ago

Small list, I think unrelated to this, maybe the Anonymous should be fixed?

402006298: expected Anonymus found Danby, John
402006298: expected Anonymus found Schmidt, Johann Philipp Samuel
406000970: expected Munzinger, Edgar found
406001593: expected Fröhlich, Friedrich Theodor found
407001151: expected Huber, Ferdinand Fürchtegott found
407001151: expected Huber, Ferdinand Fürchtegott found
407001269: expected Huber, Ferdinand Fürchtegott found
407001269: expected Huber, Ferdinand Fürchtegott found Kreutzer, Conradin
407001323: expected Huber, Ferdinand Fürchtegott found
408001438: expected Anonymus found
408001438: expected Anonymus found
408001438: expected Anonymus found
408001438: expected Anonymus found
408001438: expected Anonymus found
408001572: expected Anonymus found
408001572: expected Anonymus found
408002339: expected Anonymus found
408002339: expected Anonymus found
408002339: expected Anonymus found
410001727: expected Niedermeyer, Louis Abraham found Bellini, Vincenzo
410001942: expected Niedermeyer, Louis Abraham found
410001942: expected Niedermeyer, Louis Abraham found

xhero commented 6 years ago

Just for completeness, these are collections with no 100 but only one author in them

400056063 Stierlin, Ambrosius
400150012 Diener, Olga
402009693 Dittersdorf, Karl Ditters von
404000347 Zech, Markus
406003316 Dreyer, Johann Melchior
408000411 Vanhal, Johann Baptist
409000058 Neumann, Fritz
409000884 d'Alessandro, Raffaele
409000920 d'Alessandro, Raffaele
409000979 d'Alessandro, Raffaele
409001010 d'Alessandro, Raffaele
409001038 d'Alessandro, Raffaele
409001103 d'Alessandro, Raffaele
409001128 d'Alessandro, Raffaele
409001150 d'Alessandro, Raffaele
409001174 d'Alessandro, Raffaele
409001185 d'Alessandro, Raffaele
409001197 d'Alessandro, Raffaele
409001206 d'Alessandro, Raffaele
409001612 Roelli, Hans
409003553 Dittersdorf, Karl Ditters von
410002605 Juon, Paul
410004255 Reichel, Adolf
410004892 Gluck, Christoph Willibald
410005896 Laquai, Clara

xhero commented 6 years ago

From @lpugin on February 21, 2018 10:22

Just for completeness, these are collections with no 100 but only one author in them

It seems that the collection should get a 100

xhero commented 6 years ago

From @lpugin on February 21, 2018 10:26

Previous list, we have various cases. For example,

402006298: expected Anonymus found Danby, John 402006298: expected Anonymus found Schmidt, Johann Philipp Samuel

means that 402006298 is a collection with multiple composers.

It should be easy to correct them by hand. @cgueggi : who do you want to do this?

xhero commented 6 years ago

Another thing: 593 is the material groups, should all the groups have "autograph" for the collection to become autograph too?

xhero commented 6 years ago

This also happens in the collection for example:

http://www.rism-ch.org/admin/sources/400100920/

bonus for the second child that has an Autograph and Manuscript with autograph annotations in two different groups

xhero commented 6 years ago

From @lpugin on February 21, 2018 11:45

As I said, if all the child sources have at least one material group being Autograph, then the collection should be Autograph. @cgueggi OK?

xhero commented 6 years ago

These are all the collections that have two or more material groups, and have children with one or more Autographs inside. I think is it better to fix them by hand so the material groups can be matched

xhero commented 6 years ago

From @cgueggi on February 22, 2018 8:47

@lpugin The collection should have as many material groups as the children @xhero Corrections by hand is ok for me. Please assign Claudio for that

xhero commented 6 years ago

@lpugin The collection should have as many material groups as the children

Another thing to check ;)

xhero commented 6 years ago

From @lpugin on February 23, 2018 8:12

I was not aware of this... Yes, definitely to check.

xhero commented 6 years ago

From @baccia on February 26, 2018 8:57

OK, I’ll go through the lists.

On 22 Feb 2018, at 09:47, cgueggi notifications@github.com wrote:

@lpugin The collection should have as many material groups as the children @xhero Corrections by hand is ok for me. Please assign Claudio for that

— You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or mute the thread.

Dr. Claudio Bacciagaluppi

Swiss RISM Office Hallwylstrasse 15 PO box 286 CH-3000 Bern 6

Tel. +41 (0)58 465 03 59 Mob. +41 (0)76 503 30 71 e-mail: claudio.bacciagaluppi@rism-ch.org www.rism-ch.org

(working days: Monday, Tuesday)

xhero commented 6 years ago

I made a text list of all the collections that have a different number of 593 in respect to the children. How should we proceed? I can do automatically when there is a 1:1 correspondence surely.

collecion_multiple_593_multi_child.txt

xhero commented 6 years ago

From @baccia on February 27, 2018 16:15

Thanks for the list! As far as I have seen, I must go through them by hand. In some instances, no correction is necessary: e.g., when one material group is a score, and another one are parts for one only of the works in the collection. In other instances, the material groups in the parent record have to be sorted out again because the ‘autograph’ category was only used in the child records.

On 27 Feb 2018, at 15:44, xhero notifications@github.com wrote:

I made a text list of all the collections that have a different number of 593 in respect to the children. How should we proceed? I can do automatically when there is a 1:1 correspondence surely.

collecion_multiple_593_multi_child.txt

— You are receiving this because you commented. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or mute the thread.

Dr. Claudio Bacciagaluppi

Swiss RISM Office Hallwylstrasse 15 PO box 286 CH-3000 Bern 6

Tel. +41 (0)58 465 03 59 Mob. +41 (0)76 503 30 71 e-mail: claudio.bacciagaluppi@rism-ch.org www.rism-ch.org

(working days: Monday, Tuesday)

xhero commented 6 years ago

From @baccia on April 11, 2018 7:49

Checked by hand: collections with varying number of groups between parent and children; collections with no 100 but only one author; collections with 100 but different authors.

xhero commented 6 years ago

From @baccia on April 11, 2018 7:53

In other words, @xhero: now you can proceed automatically with all collections with only one 593='manuscript' and 100=700 'copyist'.

rism-ch / rism-maintenance

Change autograph collections 593 and remove 700 #1