rism-digital / verovio

🎵 Music notation engraving library for MEI with MusicXML and Humdrum support and various toolkits (JavaScript, Python)
https://www.verovio.org
GNU Lesser General Public License v3.0
680 stars 185 forks source link

voice problem in two voices #3752

Closed dajun-TT closed 2 months ago

dajun-TT commented 2 months ago

Describe the problem When an augmented octave is tied to the last measure, it causes the second voice to lose the effect of the augmented octave, with the actual melody being played at the original pitch (in the case of only two voices). image image

dajun-TT commented 2 months ago

Similarly, when applying diminished octaves, augmented 15ths, or diminished 15ths, the effect is the same. Even though they fall within the tied range, the pitch remains at the original pitch. image image

craigsapp commented 2 months ago

Your description is not understandable because you do not use musical terms in a standard manner (e.g., "tie", "augmented", "diminished").

To make the problem clear and allow fixing of the problem, you must provide input data that produces the music notation you provide (either in MusicXML or MEI format).

You can attach musical examples by dragging a MusicXML or MEI file onto the message, maybe in a ZIP file (images of the input data are not useful because the input data is needed to reproduce the problem and use to fix the problem).

For smaller example files less than about 1000 lines, you can paste the MusicXML/MEI file's contents directly into the website:

```xml
[paste contents of MusicXML or MEI file here]

For longer examples, it is better to paste into the message in this format:
Click to view MEI/MusicXML example data ```xml [paste contents of MusicXML or MEI file here] ```
lpugin commented 2 months ago

Unless proven otherwise this is a problem in the data.