Combining compile & link with Clang results in erroneous entry

[roubert]

Create any trivial Hello, World! style program and combine compile & link on the command line like this:

$ g++-13 -o hello hello.cc
$ clang++-17 -o hello hello.cc

That's a perfectly normal thing to do and should work perfectly fine.

Then do that through Bear:

$ bear -- g++-13 -o hello hello.cc

That works fine and generates a compile_commands.json file with a single entry, which contains exactly that one single command line, just as expected.

Then do that with Clang instead:

$ bear -- clang++-17 -o hello hello.cc

That generates a compile_commands.json file with two different entries, one with that one single command line plus one for the underlying execution of the compile step, with a very long arguments list.

This is a problem because that internal command line for the internal compile step can't be executed directly from the command line and trying to use this compilation database with Clang-Tidy will therefore result in a compilation error:

$ clang-tidy-17 -checks='*' hello.cc
[…]
error: error reading 'pic': No such file or directory [clang-diagnostic-error]

That pic comes from the internal command line, which shouldn't have been included in the compile_commands.json file.

This happens both with the Bear 3.1.3 release and with Bear built from source at current HEAD.

[rizsotto]

Hey @roubert , thanks for the report.

Clang has a "driver" which implements the GCC command line, and it calls itself with the more verbose command line flags. Is this the issue? (It means the second entry is not the linking, but the same compiling pass.)

Could you send me the output?

[roubert]

compile_commands.json

[roubert]

Have you had the chance to look into this and can you confirm that it's an issue with Bear (that would be useful to fix)?