rjournal / rjtools

Tools for AUTHORS to use for checking and submitting articles to the R Journal
https://rjournal.github.io/rjtools/
Other
31 stars 14 forks source link

Use section numbering consistently in PDF versions #61

Closed zeileis closed 1 year ago

zeileis commented 1 year ago

The RJournal.sty shipped in rjtools was updated last year to provide section numbers also in PDF versions of R Journal contributions: https://github.com/rjournal/rjtools/commit/c07c4590d53d45a85ef2d5506e4ced42f8dbcc93 Note, however, that this update hasn't propagated everywhere:

I'm not sure whether there are other versions floating around that should be updated.

I would also recommend to explicitly create a new version for this. The file claims to be

\ProvidesPackage{RJournal}[2013/08/27 v0.13 RJournal package]

but it really isn't anymore. This may create confusion and you may also end up using the wrong style file. For example, David Kaplan's knitrdata paper in the most recent R Journal volume does not have section numbers in the PDF version: https://journal.R-project.org/articles/RJ-2023-001/RJ-2023-001.pdf Checking the underlying sources, it turns out that he included an RJournal.sty version that still excluded version numbering. Of course, this may have been a conscious decision but probably not. See: https://github.com/rjournal/rjournal.github.io/blob/master/_articles/RJ-2023-001/RJournal.sty#L106

mitchelloharawild commented 1 year ago

Thanks for reporting this issue for the rticles maintainers, I am unsure if they plan to continue providing the rjournal article format in their package as we encourage submissions in the rjtools HTML/PDF format.

@dicook - could we update this RJtemplate.zip resource for changes to RJournal.sty?

I will bump the version, thank you for this. I am somewhat unfamiliar with tex package formalities.