VnV Review: Actionable Review Plan

[Tan630]

I appreciate that you are involving another domain expert (Dr. Onaizah). You have also exactly described the items to review, which is good.

Please also consider providing a checklist of verifiable criteria, such as

• [ ] Does the project sufficiently capture the problem?
  • [ ] Is the problem sufficiently motivated?
• [ ] Is the theory sound?
• [ ] Is the language correct? (e.g. if there is any abuse of notation/language that are not made explicit, incorrect use of terms, etc.)
• [ ] Do solving goals solve the problem?
  • [ ] Do fulfilling requirements achieve the corresponding goals? Doing so makes the review more structured, and feedbacks more actionable.