search

robaho / seashore

easy to use mac osx image editing application for the rest of us
GNU General Public License v2.0
454 stars 20 forks source link

Can Seashore be a macOS Photos extension? #214

Open davidhercher opened 1 week ago

davidhercher commented 1 week ago

I'd like to use Seashore to edit photos in macOS Photos by using Seashore as an extension. I have the current macOS (15.0) and Photos (1.0, 701.0.220). In Photos, after selecting a photo and then choosing Edit | three dots in the tool bar, I see Markup above the line and App Store and Manage below it. Choosing App Store identifies only seven Mac App Store apps as candidates to use as a Photos Extension, and Seashore is not one of the seven, even though it's available in the Mac App store. When I choose Manage, I see a list of extensions, including extensions to Spotlight, which has a list including Seashore. But I don't see how actually to see Seashore within Photos.

Can Seashore be used in Photos as an extension? Or is it usable only outside Photos? Thanks.

robaho commented 1 week ago

Thanks for reporting this. This used to work. I’ll get it fixed this week.

davidhercher commented 1 week ago

That’s great. Would you expect it to be on the list of available extensions when choosing App Store? I’m surprised that only seven appear there. Thanks.

robaho commented 1 week ago

No. It will be available with “edit with”. I may be able to support the App Store but I’d have to look into it.

robaho commented 1 week ago

Also your email replies are corrupted. I needed to edit it. Please update the issue using a browser.

robaho commented 1 week ago

@davidhercher A 'Photos' edit extension requires OSX 10.11 and Seashore minimum is 10.9 so it is a bit of work.

You should be able to right-click the image in the gallery/list view in Photos and use Edit -> and Seashore should appear here. The image when saved will appear saved as a version in Photos as well. Does this work for you?

robaho commented 1 week ago

I did notice one issue, if you use Edit, then close and save at the close, it doesn't work. You need to manually Save in the editor first. I will look into this.

davidhercher commented 1 week ago

Thank you for your time on this project. Two remaining questions: (1) After saving changes made in Seashore, is it possible to revert to the original image, as it is after editing using Photos itself; and (2) Is it correct that Seashore, although available in the Mac App Store, can't be added to Photos' internal extension list via selecting photo | Edit | three dots | App Store. When I do the latter, I see seven apps on the Mac App Store, not including Seashore. If one of the seven is chosen, it appears in the drop-down extension list under the three dotes. Thanks again.

robaho commented 1 week ago
  1. It doesn't appear so. I believe this used to be the case but I think Apple has removed this feature. The "Revert To Original" is grayed out. I am going to look a bit more into this to see if there are options to turn it on.
  2. As I mentioned above, a Photos Extension requires OSX 10.11 to implement which is outside the minimum Seashore version. I'm not saying it would be impossible to implement, but it will be a bit of effort, but at this time Seashore is not a Photos Extension.