robotology / stereo-vision

Repository containing apps for stereo vision
https://robotology.github.io/stereo-vision/
GNU General Public License v2.0
19 stars 19 forks source link

now ELAS library is used by default to compute horizontal disparity map from rectified images #1

Closed GiuliaP closed 9 years ago

GiuliaP commented 9 years ago
pattacini commented 9 years ago

Thanks @GiuliaP could you provide doxygen documentation about the modifications you applied (e.g. the --use_sgbm option, the two new ports ...)? I will be able then to recompile the documentation.

@Tobias-Fischer here's the PR; feel free to participate/test/contribute.

GiuliaP commented 9 years ago

Sure, thank you!

Tobias-Fischer commented 9 years ago

Hi @GiuliaP,

Thanks for the nice contribution! I quickly had a look at the source code, and except for some smaller comments it looks all good (see above & in https://github.com/GiuliaP/stereo-vision/commit/7b1eb3889396a2b2719dc93178be3a685d1fc05e, sorry for being picky ;) ). I'll give it a try on our robot in the next couple of days and let you know how the accuracy is.

Thanks again and best wishes, Tobias

pattacini commented 9 years ago

Thanks @GiuliaP :+1:

GiuliaP commented 9 years ago

@Tobias-Fischer @pattacini Following your observations about the different settings of parameters, I'm modifying the code, providing the possibility of tuning some more parameters. I'll also do some other tests on our robot, trying to define the best configuration. I'll let you know when everything is ready to be tested!

pattacini commented 9 years ago

yes, the idea is to test the final settings along with the depth2kin experiment, to see whether the finger will be always detected.

Tobias-Fischer commented 9 years ago

Hi @GiuliaP: Thanks a lot for your effort! Please let me know once you tuned the parameter set on your robot, and I'll give it a try on ours. Best, Tobias

Tariq-Abuhashim commented 9 years ago

Hi;

Please note that unlike opencv, which performs dense texture matching, ELAS estimates the dense disparity using MRFs (hence it is faster). Therefore, these parameters are going to be scene/application dependent based on how much smoothness is assumed.

Best regards; Tariq Abuhashim

On Thu, Jun 11, 2015 at 10:38 AM, Tobias Fischer notifications@github.com wrote:

Hi @GiuliaP https://github.com/GiuliaP: Thanks a lot for your effort! Please let me know once you tuned the parameter set on your robot, and I'll give it a try on ours. Best, Tobias

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub https://github.com/robotology/stereo-vision/pull/1#issuecomment-111042954 .

GiuliaP commented 9 years ago

@pattacini @Tariq-Abuhashim @Tobias-Fischer I have pushed another commit where I have:

pattacini commented 9 years ago

Preliminary tests run with depth2kin along with default parameters of SFM showed a good segmentation!