roboyoshi / datacurator-filetree

a standard filetree for /r/datacurator [ and r/datahoarder ]
https://reddit.com/r/datacurator
MIT License
1.46k stars 137 forks source link

feat: Add VHS section #65

Closed fionera closed 3 years ago

fionera commented 3 years ago

Closes #64

roboyoshi commented 3 years ago

I think this is fine, but I'm thinking about including stuff like betamax as well. If we are talking plain media dumps, then I had the untouched / discs / raw folders. Whatever you wanna call it, but it can include any 1:1 copies. The problem with VHS is that you cannot really have a 1:1 copy, because it's analog (unless it's Digital VHS). I would probably create a discs and tapes folder and have it like this:

video/
  discs/
    dvd
    bd
    ...
  tapes/
    vhs
    betamax
    ...

or just all in one folder:

video/
  untouched/ | raw/ | dump/
    dvd
    bd
    vhs
    betamax
    ...

Worth reading:

In the last overview it becomes clearer that there are currently 4 major types of our "untouched" media formats: (magnetic) tapes, (optical) discs, virtual (files) and film

The video section is often divided in media for consumption and media for archival. I would either move the "untouched" media out of the video dir and into archive/video/<tape|disc|virtual|film> or create a dedicated directory within video/ for the <raw|untouched|master> media. Naming wise, it depends a bit on your content as well. If you want to keep the original files of your RED camera that you used for shooting a movie, then MASTER and RAW is more appropriate. If we talk about simple BD50 dumps, then DUMPS or UNTOUCHED may be more fitting.

I think I will extend this PR with this information.. Simply putting vhs inside video is too simple though. It's just 1 type of tape that became popular, but there is so much more.

fionera commented 3 years ago

I would go with the first one since it allows more easy access and is more intuitive. Also it doesnt change the current order of data.

roboyoshi commented 3 years ago

I'm merging this for now and will adjust the structure as mentioned above. Thanks for contributing!