search

rockowitz / ddcutil

Control monitor settings using DDC/CI and USB
http://www.ddcutil.com
GNU General Public License v2.0
989 stars 42 forks source link

ddcutil not working on Raspberry Pi 4 #97

Open fm99 opened 5 years ago

fm99 commented 5 years ago

I have tried to use ddcutil (v0.9.2 from default raspian buster repo) on my new Pi4 - unfortunately without success: When I enter "ddcutil detect" I get the message "No diplays found".

Since I use Kodi, I must use on the "GL (Fake KMS) OpenGL desktop driver with fake KMS" (see https://www.raspberrypi.org/forums/viewtopic.php?f=66&t=251645).

I then read the documentation about the Raspberry Pi on www.ddcutil.com and played around with the i2c related dtparam settings. Still no success.

Finally, I downloaded the source code of the latest version of ddcutil (v0.9.7) and compiled it. That didn't help either.

Please find enclosed my current /boot/config.txt and various ddcutil diagnostic reports:

Thank you for any help.

rockowitz commented 5 years ago

Are you and user marmaladeseismic the same?   Rather a coincidence to see two posts re the Raspberry Pi on the same day.

Looking at your environment command output, there are no slave addresses active on /dev/i2c-2, including x50 and x37.  This is the case whether using ddcutil's I2C access, or command i2cdetect.  So it would appear to be an I2C configuration problem.  The Raspberry Pi is not a platform I normally test on - the last time I looked at it in any depth was over a year ago.   A couple questions come to mind, but they're pretty basic.  What happens if you do not use Kodi?  Does ddcutil work for you on a Pi 3?

Note that for testing purposes, you can use command i2cdetect.  If i2cdetect does not find slave addresses x50 and x37 on the I2C bus, there's no point in trying to use ddcutil.

Sorry that I can't be of more help.  If you do find a solution please post it here so that others can see it and I can include it in the documentation.

Sanford

On 10/26/19 6:36 PM, fm99 wrote:

ddcutil not working on Raspberry Pi 4

I have tried to use ddcutil (v0.9.2 from default raspian buster repo) on my new Pi4 - unfortunately without success: When I enter "ddcutil detect" I get the message "No diplays found".

Since I use Kodi, I must use on the "GL (Fake KMS) OpenGL desktop driver with fake KMS" (see https://www.raspberrypi.org/forums/viewtopic.php?f=66&t=251645).

I then read the documentation about the Raspberry Pi on www.ddcutil.com http://www.ddcutil.com and played around with the i2c related dtparam settings. Still no success.

Finally, I downloaded the source code of the latest version of ddcutil (v0.9.7) and compiled it. That didn't help either.

Please find enclosed my current /boot/config.txt and various ddcutil diagnostic reports:

*

boot-config.txt
<https://github.com/rockowitz/ddcutil/files/3775326/boot-config.txt>

*

ddcutil detect --verbose.txt
<https://github.com/rockowitz/ddcutil/files/3775327/ddcutil.detect.--verbose.txt>

*

ddcutil environment --verbose.txt
<https://github.com/rockowitz/ddcutil/files/3775328/ddcutil.environment.--verbose.txt>

*

ddcutil interrogate.txt
<https://github.com/rockowitz/ddcutil/files/3775329/ddcutil.interrogate.txt>

Thank you for any help.

— You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/rockowitz/ddcutil/issues/97?email_source=notifications&email_token=ADMGY3VMV2NK355VZM5OFNLQQTA6PA5CNFSM4JFPEK22YY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFUVEXG43VMWVGG33NNVSW45C7NFSM4HUSEP4Q, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ADMGY3XB7GOFUJGBNZZWNULQQTA6PANCNFSM4JFPEK2Q.

fm99 commented 5 years ago

Hi Sanford

Thanks for your answer.

As for your questions/points:

  1. "Are you and user marmaladeseismic the same?" => No, I'm not that other user, it's just a coincidence.
  2. "What happens if you do not use Kodi?" => If I configure the "Original non-GL desktop driver" (i.e. if only one or more I2C dtparam lines but no GL driver related dtoverlay line is set in /boot/config.txt), ddcutil doesn't work either ("No diplays found").
  3. "Does ddcutil work for you on a Pi 3?" => I have two Pi 3B+, one running debian/raspbian 9 (stretch) and one running debian/raspbian 10 (buster). On both Pis ddcutil runs as expected, i.e. I can read/change the settings of my monitor without any problems.
  4. "Sorry that I can't be of more help. If you do find a solution please post it here so that others can see it and I can include it in the documentation." => That is not a problem. I was pleased that you reacted so quickly to my request. If I find a solution, I will describe it as a comment here. Thanks again for your help!

Update: I found this discussion on the kernel source tree for the Pi: https://github.com/raspberrypi/linux/issues/3152. As I understand it, I2C support for the Pi4 is still incomplete at the moment, so ddcutil cannot be used on a Pi4 for now :-/

bangom commented 4 years ago

Hi Sanford

Thanks for your answer.

As for your questions/points:

  1. "Are you and user marmaladeseismic the same?" => No, I'm not that other user, it's just a coincidence.
  2. "What happens if you do not use Kodi?" => If I configure the "Original non-GL desktop driver" (i.e. if only one or more I2C dtparam lines but no GL driver related dtoverlay line is set in /boot/config.txt), ddcutil doesn't work either ("No diplays found").
  3. "Does ddcutil work for you on a Pi 3?" => I have two Pi 3B+, one running debian/raspbian 9 (stretch) and one running debian/raspbian 10 (buster). On both Pis ddcutil runs as expected, i.e. I can read/change the settings of my monitor without any problems.
  4. "Sorry that I can't be of more help. If you do find a solution please post it here so that others can see it and I can include it in the documentation." => That is not a problem. I was pleased that you reacted so quickly to my request. If I find a solution, I will describe it as a comment here. Thanks again for your help!

Update: I found this discussion on the kernel source tree for the Pi: raspberrypi/linux#3152. As I understand it, I2C support for the Pi4 is still incomplete at the moment, so ddcutil cannot be used on a Pi4 for now :-/

IMHO, this is not a ddcutil problem. I2C on RPI4 is OK in general... The problem with ddcutil on RPI4 is that HDMI DDC/CI (I2C) is not accessible in userspace (/dev/i2c-2) due to completely new HW comparing to RPI3 (RPI4 drivers need to be fixed).

As a workaround, you can physically connect HDMI DDC/CI to free i2c bus on RPI4 and control it with ddcutil - details see my post here: https://github.com/raspberrypi/linux/issues/3152.

rockowitz commented 4 years ago

Thanks for the detailed report.  I'll update the Pi documentation at www.ddcutil.com/raspberry.

On 1/1/20 9:53 PM, bangom wrote:

Hi Sanford

Thanks for your answer.

As for your questions/points:

 1. "Are you and user marmaladeseismic the same?" => No, I'm not
    that other user, it's just a coincidence.
 2. "What happens if you do not use Kodi?" => If I configure the
    "Original non-GL desktop driver" (i.e. if only one or more I2C
    dtparam lines but no GL driver related dtoverlay line is set
    in /boot/config.txt), ddcutil doesn't work either ("No diplays
    found").
 3. "Does ddcutil work for you on a Pi 3?" => I have two Pi 3B+,
    one running debian/raspbian 9 (stretch) and one running
    debian/raspbian 10 (buster). On both Pis ddcutil runs as
    expected, i.e. I can read/change the settings of my monitor
    without any problems.
 4. "Sorry that I can't be of more help. If you do find a solution
    please post it here so that others can see it and I can
    include it in the documentation." => That is not a problem. I
    was pleased that you reacted so quickly to my request. If I
    find a solution, I will describe it as a comment here. Thanks
    again for your help!

Update: I found this discussion on the kernel source tree for the
Pi: raspberrypi/linux#3152
<https://github.com/raspberrypi/linux/issues/3152>.
As I understand it, I2C support for the Pi4 is still incomplete at
the moment, so ddcutil cannot be used on a Pi4 for now :-/

IMHO, this is not a ddcutil problem. I2C on RPI4 is OK in general... The problem with ddcutil on RPI4 is that HDMI DDC/CI (I2C) is not accessible in userspace (/dev/i2c-2) due to completely new HW comparing to RPI3 (RPI4 drivers need to be fixed).

As a workaround, you can physically connect HDMI DDC/CI to free i2c bus on RPI4 and control it with ddcutil - details see my post here: raspberrypi/linux#3152 https://github.com/raspberrypi/linux/issues/3152.

— You are receiving this because you commented. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/rockowitz/ddcutil/issues/97?email_source=notifications&email_token=ADMGY3VISSVAGRRD2XUJDULQ3VJK3A5CNFSM4JFPEK22YY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFVREXG43VMVBW63LNMVXHJKTDN5WW2ZLOORPWSZGOEH5SMAY#issuecomment-570107395, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ADMGY3XXTIJNMA2Q5Q3HXH3Q3VJK3ANCNFSM4JFPEK2Q.

rockowitz commented 4 years ago

Page www.ddcutil.com/raspberry has been updated to reflect this information.

Thanks again,

On 1/1/20 9:53 PM, bangom wrote:

Hi Sanford

Thanks for your answer.

As for your questions/points:

 1. "Are you and user marmaladeseismic the same?" => No, I'm not
    that other user, it's just a coincidence.
 2. "What happens if you do not use Kodi?" => If I configure the
    "Original non-GL desktop driver" (i.e. if only one or more I2C
    dtparam lines but no GL driver related dtoverlay line is set
    in /boot/config.txt), ddcutil doesn't work either ("No diplays
    found").
 3. "Does ddcutil work for you on a Pi 3?" => I have two Pi 3B+,
    one running debian/raspbian 9 (stretch) and one running
    debian/raspbian 10 (buster). On both Pis ddcutil runs as
    expected, i.e. I can read/change the settings of my monitor
    without any problems.
 4. "Sorry that I can't be of more help. If you do find a solution
    please post it here so that others can see it and I can
    include it in the documentation." => That is not a problem. I
    was pleased that you reacted so quickly to my request. If I
    find a solution, I will describe it as a comment here. Thanks
    again for your help!

Update: I found this discussion on the kernel source tree for the
Pi: raspberrypi/linux#3152
<https://github.com/raspberrypi/linux/issues/3152>.
As I understand it, I2C support for the Pi4 is still incomplete at
the moment, so ddcutil cannot be used on a Pi4 for now :-/

IMHO, this is not a ddcutil problem. I2C on RPI4 is OK in general... The problem with ddcutil on RPI4 is that HDMI DDC/CI (I2C) is not accessible in userspace (/dev/i2c-2) due to completely new HW comparing to RPI3 (RPI4 drivers need to be fixed).

As a workaround, you can physically connect HDMI DDC/CI to free i2c bus on RPI4 and control it with ddcutil - details see my post here: raspberrypi/linux#3152 https://github.com/raspberrypi/linux/issues/3152.

— You are receiving this because you commented. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/rockowitz/ddcutil/issues/97?email_source=notifications&email_token=ADMGY3VISSVAGRRD2XUJDULQ3VJK3A5CNFSM4JFPEK22YY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFVREXG43VMVBW63LNMVXHJKTDN5WW2ZLOORPWSZGOEH5SMAY#issuecomment-570107395, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ADMGY3XXTIJNMA2Q5Q3HXH3Q3VJK3ANCNFSM4JFPEK2Q.

robertalexa commented 3 years ago

@rockowitz Hi,

Could you please offer your input on this?

To my knowledge, kernel 5.10 should have fixed this issue and ddcutil should now be working. However the documentation for ddcutil raspberry still says that it is unavailable for RPI4.

I am to assume that this comment is actually correct and the documentation above mentioned is outdated?

Just to make it easier for everyone, a quick step by step:

  1. run rpi-update, this should install rpi firmware 5.10
  2. in /boot/config.txt look for the [pi4] section and set this value dtoverlay=vc4-kms-v3d
  3. reboot
  4. ddcutil detect should now detect your screen (is ddc capable of course...)

Many thanks, Rob

rockowitz commented 3 years ago

@robertalexa You are correct. The ddcutil Raspberry Pi documentation is badly out of date. I was not aware that I2C was now working over HDMI on the Pi 4. I've been meaning to put together a Pi 4 for testing, but that's backed up behind a lot of other things (like getting out a new release).

If you'd be willing to send me modified content for ddcutil's Pi page, I'll modify the page accordingly.

robertalexa commented 3 years ago

@rockowitz at the minute i am stacked, but i am hoping that some time this weekend i will find the time to test this at my end, make note of requirements and after that i will post another reply for the documentation. Leave this with me for a bit

robertalexa commented 3 years ago

@rockowitz hey man. Just had a chance to have a play with this and everything is good :)

In order for this to work:

  1. make sure you are at least on firmware 5.10 - this is now mainstream, so sudo apt update && sudo apt upgrade will be sufficient.
  2. In /boot/config.txt look for the [pi4] section and set replace dtoverlay=vc4-fkms-v3d with dtoverlay=vc4-kms-v3d
  3. In /etc/modules add i2c_dev
  4. Reboot
  5. Install ddcutil - sudo apt install ddcutil
  6. Done

Check if everything is working and your monitor is detected: ddcutil detect The output should be similar to this

Display 1 I2C bus: /dev/i2c-12 EDID synopsis: Mfg id: BNQ Model: BenQ GW2270 Serial number: AAF03393019 Manufacture year: 2015 EDID version: 1.3 VCP version: 2.1

Find out what commands you can run on your monitor: ddcutil capabilities Check the command overview page for how to read and write your monitor parameters.

Hope this is good enough to put on the Documentation page. With this in mind, you can probably close the Issue as everything is now working.

Offtopic: do you have any experience with controlling screen brightness based on room light using a LDR? Thanks

rockowitz commented 3 years ago

Robert,

I have updated the ddcutil Raspberry Pi page based on your documentation. Let me know if it looks right to you.

I have no direct experience controlling screen brightness using a LDR, but it seems to me there are 3 parts to the question:

robertalexa commented 3 years ago

@rockowitz I have seen the docs earlier today and it looks good :) nice one for updating it!

As to the LDR, i know how to achieve it on paper, i am just not sure how often i should be sending updates to a monitor without any risks. If you think about a phone for example, I am sure you know how the screen brightness gradually adjusts when changing the ambient light. It is after this effect that I am after.

So to achieve sth as smooth as that, there will be more than one single VCP value involved, probably 1 by 1 for the duration of say 1 second. But I am unsure if there are any risks associated with "flooding" the monitor with such quick successive changes.

Anyway, thanks for your input, it is much appreciated :)

rockowitz commented 3 years ago

@robertalexa offtopic LDR discussion moved to issue #197