search

rocky-linux / sig-cloud-instance-images

47 stars 7 forks source link

rockylinux:9 image missing /sbin/init or /usr/sbin/init #39

Closed hwdsl2 closed 3 months ago

hwdsl2 commented 1 year ago

The latest version of rockylinux:9 image is missing /sbin/init (or /usr/sbin/init). Therefore the "Systemd integration" instructions do not work with the latest image version. See: https://hub.docker.com/r/rockylinux/rockylinux

I am aware that the official image is at https://hub.docker.com/_/rockylinux, I'm just linking to the systemd integration section in the link above.

This issue was found on Dec. 21, 2022. The Dec. 17 version of the rockylinux:9 image worked fine and has this file.

@NeilHanlon

Thank you for looking into this possible regression.

NeilHanlon commented 1 year ago

Hi -

I apologize for the extreme latency on responding to this issue. I will investigate adding the init binary to the container in 8.8. It was removed while building the 8.7 images due to systemd polluting the build root and init not being actually a necessary component for most container users, due to container philosophy of running a single thing in a container.

We recognize that users do need/want init containers, and so I would recommend users who need init available use the ubi variants of the container images which provide the init/systemd binaries.

We also have a PR open to add ubi-micro and ubi-init variants, the latter of which would automatically have init set as an entrypoint. #42