roll-wg draft-ietf-roll-enrollment-priority issues

roll-wg / draft-ietf-roll-enrollment-priority

This document provides a mechanism by which a RPL DODAG root can disable join announcements, or adjust the base priority for join operation.

2 stars 3 forks source link

issues

Newest

Newest Most commented Recently updated Oldest Least commented Least recently updated

Content-free Appendix A can be removed.

#32 ariskou closed 2 weeks ago
1
Duplicate “the the”.

#31 ariskou closed 2 weeks ago
1
Some English grammar suggestions (“like” vs “such as”, “that” vs “which” usage).

#30 ariskou closed 2 weeks ago
1
Use consistent casing of some terms that are presently inconsistent.

#29 ariskou closed 2 weeks ago
1
Expand acronyms on first use that the RFC editor’s abbreviation list doesn’t have an asterisk by.

#28 ariskou opened 2 weeks ago
1
The doc says “the DODAG size may slightly change between a DIO and the next, so the value transmitted MUST be considered as an approximation” but it’s not clear what it means to “consider it as an approximation”. So how can you tell whether this MUST is met or not? Either don’t use MUST or give a more concrete explanation as to what that means.

#27 ariskou closed 2 weeks ago
1
The DODAG size is specified as a multiple of a power of 2. If the actual size always such a multiple, or do you round up or round down?

#26 ariskou closed 2 weeks ago
1
Clarify wording around definition of enrollment vs onboarding

#25 ariskou opened 2 weeks ago
1
The term "(lack of) willingness" is awkward. Do you mean ability or inability or relative priority or something like that. Again, anthropomorphic.

#24 ariskou opened 2 weeks ago
1
Avoid anthropomorphic language (i.e., friendly proxy)

#23 ariskou closed 2 weeks ago
1
Either expand acronyms on their first use or include a Terminology section

#22 ariskou opened 2 weeks ago
1
Update 6tisch-roll-enrollment-priority.mkd

#21 konrad-iwanicki closed 1 month ago
0
Issues from Review of Review of draft-ietf-roll-enrollment-priority-10

#20 TAU-MariaInesRobles opened 4 months ago
0
Rtg Review - Nits

#19 inesrob opened 7 months ago
0
Security Directorate Review

#18 inesrob opened 7 months ago
0
change DODAG size to 1 byte

#17 mcr closed 11 months ago
1
Update 6tisch-roll-enrollment-priority.mkd

#16 konrad-iwanicki closed 1 year ago
0
Integrate after Michael applied my minor comments.

#15 konrad-iwanicki closed 1 year ago
1
Propose changes to reflect major points of our discussion

#14 konrad-iwanicki closed 1 year ago
8
add explicit lollipop counter into enrollment priority option

#13 mcr closed 8 months ago
2
should root explicitedly reset trickle timer?

#12 mcr closed 8 months ago
6
what EB and priority, if any should a node with no feasible parent emit?

#11 mcr closed 8 months ago
1
should priority have more than 1 bit: join disabled/enabled?

#10 mcr closed 8 months ago
1
adapt document to priority not changing through the DODAG

#9 mcr closed 1 year ago
4
unwrap sentences to start on newlines, removed a commented out paragraph

#8 mcr closed 2 years ago
0
-05 Section 3.1, questions

#7 dbarthel-ol closed 8 months ago
1
suggests nit fixes, please review carefully

#6 dbarthel-ol closed 1 year ago
1
explain how new option values are related to DODAGVersionNumber

#5 mcr closed 8 months ago
1
enrollment priority option name

#4 mcr closed 8 months ago
1
minor nit fixes

#3 nyrahul closed 3 years ago
0
Update README.md

#2 inesrob closed 3 years ago
0
nits to fix and complete the TODO section

#1 inesrob closed 3 years ago
1