ropensci-org / blog-guidance

rOpenSci Blog Guidelines for Authors and Editors (bookdown::git_book)
https://blogguide.ropensci.org/
9 stars 4 forks source link

Consider using simpler, shorter headings #155

Closed steffilazerte closed 3 years ago

steffilazerte commented 4 years ago

Some headings in the blog guide are long enough that they're cut off, and, to me, not always intuitive. I think some could be simplified and shorted.

For example:

stefaniebutland commented 4 years ago

fyi @maelle, Steffi and I agreed she would make and refine some proposals for this and we can discuss/review/agree.

She'll ping us when ready for consideration

maelle commented 4 years ago

Awesome!

steffilazerte commented 4 years ago

Okay! I think the blog guide would benefit from short and punchy headings that are less conversational and more explicit.

I've been pretty brutal and have offered a suggestion for nearly everything. Sometimes my suggestion is more about making the title short that super explicit, but I think that long and explicit is usually worse.

At the bottom I also have some suggestions for reorganizing a couple of sections. Let me know if you think it would be simpler for me to make this a document in a new branch that you could directly edit with suggestions.

Original New
1.2 Themes of posts 1.2 Themes
1.3 What goes in your post? 1.3 Post content
2.1 Fork the repo and ... 2.1 Fork roweb3 OR Fork the repository OR Getting started
2.2 Start the post from a ... 2.2 Post template
2.3 Walkthrough with code ... 2.3 Adding content
2.3.1 What goes in YAML 2.3.1 YAML
2.3.3 To add an image 2.3.3 External images
2.3.4 To add a figure ... 2.3.4 Rmd-created images
2.3.5 To add a citation 2.3.5 Citations
2.3.6 To embed a tweet 2.3.6 Embedded tweets
2.5 Create or update your ... 2.5 Author files
2.7 Submit your draft post 2.7 Submit post OR Submit draft OR Submit draft post
3 Responding to Editor's ... 3 Respond to review OR Respond to feedback
A Post template in Markdown A Template - Post (md)
B Post template in R Markdown B Template - Post (Rmd)
C Author file template C Template - Author file
D Author checklist for a ... D Author Checklist - Posts on peer-reviewed packages *
E Author checklist for any... E Author Checklist - Other posts *
F Editor checklist for a ... F Editor checklist - Posts on peer-reviewed packages *
G Editor checklist for any... G Editor checklist - Other posts *
H Understanding Twitter cards H Twitter cards

* These would be updated in several different spots (2.6 Presubmission checks, 5.1 Review a post, and Appendix)

Other organizational suggestions

maelle commented 4 years ago

the new headings look good to me! It'll be more important to check cross-references aren't broken.