Add a new organization to ROR: EDITORA ALUMNI IN

ror-curator-bot commented 3 weeks ago

Summary of request: Add a new organization to ROR

Name of organization: Editora ALUMNI IN Website: https://alumniin.com Domains: alumniin.com Link to publications: https://doi.org/10.37497 Organization type: Other (Use this category for any organization that does not fit the categories above) Wikipedia page: Wikidata ID: ISNI ID: GRID ID: Crossref Funder ID:
Aliases: ALUMNI IN Labels: Acronym/abbreviation: Related organizations: City: SÃO PAULO Country: BRAZIL Geonames ID: Year established: 2020 How will a ROR ID for this organization be used? To identify affiliations for research publications, To identify affiliations for datasets, To be integrated in a scholarly publishing system

Other information about this request:

ror-curator-bot commented 3 weeks ago

adambuttrick commented 3 weeks ago

Publisher in Brazil. Extent of publications and journals look generally fine, but affiliation usage appears to be exclusively derived from usage by editors in journals that are published by the publisher. At least two have external indexing in LatIndex (International Journal of Health Management Review and Revista Latino-americana de Governança) so this may be fine to add, but would appreciate a second review.

ssmulyan commented 1 week ago

We wouldn't necessarily expect extensive affiliation usage for publishers. Their organizational status, extent of publications, and third party indexing (at least for some of the journals) all look okay. They also claim to use COPE guidance in ethics.

However, this is the list of titles registered in Crossref by Editora Alumni in (and the number of articles registered for each title)

"Revista do CEJUR/TJSC: Prestação Jurisdicional": 94, "Revista Trabalho, Direito e Justiça": 64, "Journal of Medical Residency Review": 52, "CAMPO JURÍDICO": 45, "ESG Law Review": 41, "Revista FAPAD - Revista da Faculdade Pan-Americana de Administração e Direito": 38, "Journal of Law and Corruption Review": 33, "Colloquium: health and education": 30, "Review of Artificial Intelligence in Education": 29, "Revista Eletrônica ESA-SC": 22, "Revista Latino-americana de Governança": 21, "Journal of Law and Sustainable Development": 15, "ESG Studies Review": 10, "Review of Sdgs in Emerging Countries": 7, "SDGs Studies Review": 3, "Revista Pan-americana de Direito": 3

This is the list of titles they say the publish on their website:

Journal of Health Management Review Journal of Lifestyle and SDGs Review Future Studies Research Journal Journal of Medical Residency Review Revista Inteligência Competitiva Revista de Governança Corporativa REVISTA GESTÃO E TECNOLOGIA Revista Prestação Jurisdicional Retail Management Review JOURNAL OF URBAN TECHNOLOGY AND SUSTAINABILITY Review of Artificial Intelligence in Education ESG Law Review Journal of Law and Corruption Review Revista Latino-Americana de Governança Open Science Brazil

There is some overlap, but also substantial deviation.

Some of this might be due to translation issues. But I check the info for a number of the journals they list as publishing, and it's hard to tell whether they have any relationship to Editora Allumni In

Journal of Health Management Review, for example, is registered with Crossref by a completely different publisher, South Florida Publishing LLC (10.47172), and there's no mention of Editora Alumni in on the journal's site. The same is true for Journal of Lifestyle and SDGs Review, which doesn't link successfully from the Editora Alumni In site, but does have a working journal site at https://sdgsreview.org/LifestyleJournal/index

Future Studies Research Journal is an independent Crossref member - Future Studies Research Journal: Trends and Strategies (10.24023) - there's nothing on their site that indicates a relationship with Editora Alumni In https://www.revistafuture.org/FSRJ/index

If I start from the other direction and look at the content that Editora Alumni In has registered with Crossref, for example, Revista do CEJUR/TJSC: Prestação Jurisdicional has the most content. That is listed among their publications on their publisher site, but in that case the journal site also doesn't name them as a publisher. So, that may not be as useful as a rubric as I thought it would.
https://revistadocejur.tjsc.jus.br/cejur/article/view/429

They may still be fine to add, but I'd suggest that we ask for clarification on the extent of their publications and whether they have working relationships with all the journals they claim to.

adambuttrick commented 1 week ago

Declining until requestor can resolve inconsistencies documented in curator review.

ror-community / ror-updates

Add a new organization to ROR: EDITORA ALUMNI IN #13407