First Foxy release - Githubissues

bmagyar commented 4 years ago

List of required features from ros2_control and ros2_controllers for the first Foxy release:

The joint_trajectory_controller from ROS Melodic with all it's features
The diff_drive_controller from ROS Melodic with all it's features
gazebo_ros_control

Waiting for contributions to this list @jordan-palacios @Karsten1987 @piraka9011

bmagyar commented 4 years ago

My first list is what I think of as bare minimum.

I'd opt for shipping something now to have some functionality available but with ideally it'd be good to be able to ship some framework improvements (aka all the stuff in design docs) to Foxy too, meaning they may be slightly breaking changes, at least within the scope of framework components which we'd manage. The yearly release proposed starting from Foxy doesn't leave us with very good alternatives if we want to ship stuff in a timely manner. What are your thoughts on this guys? @Karsten1987 @jordan-palacios @piraka9011

piraka9011 commented 4 years ago

SGTM, not sure how large of a change gazebo_ros_control would be but maybe focusing on framework/infra stuff might be better?

destogl commented 4 years ago

@bmagyar, what is the best way to manage the roadmap for this? I mean the list of tasks with technical / implementation steps. We need to coordinate ourselves somehow...

Should we just open one issue, with a checklist of tasks and responsible person for it? Or ist it better to use GitHub-Project option? Has anyone experience with that? If we go the latter path, then I would need access rights to this repository.

bmagyar commented 4 years ago

How about a new section in the roadmap repo for a general outline? I can look into how we could leverage github project for the execution

piraka9011 commented 4 years ago

@bmagyar @destogl We have a zenhub board setup in the roadmap repo. It does require an extension though. A GitHub project board also works.

ruffsl commented 4 years ago

A GitHub project board also works.

+1 for project visibility and being co-located with the repo. I was checking up on gazebo_ros_control, which led me here, wondering about the state of ros2_control, and where the project roadmap was.

destogl commented 4 years ago

@ruffsl you can find it in the roadmap repository

destogl commented 4 years ago

The PRs for the release:

ros2_control:

[x] #236
[x] #240
[x] #220
[ ] #249
[x] #230
[ ] #272

ros2_controllers:

[x] joint_state_controller
[x] forward_command_controller
[x] joint_trajectory_controller

ros2_control_demos

[x] RRBotSystemHardware

Demo Robots (at least one)

[x] ABB Studio
[ ] ABB Robot
[x] KUKA Robot

gavanderhoorn commented 4 years ago

Demo Robots (at least one)
* ABB Studio
* ABB Robot
* KUKA Robot

I haven't been able to attend the meetings, so this could have been discussed there.

Could you provide some more info on availability of interfaces for the two robot OEMs you mention?

destogl commented 4 years ago

There are currently none, but people said they can provide them. I can notify you when we start to work on it.

I am not experienced with ABB. For KUKA we will be porting RSI-Driver from kuka_experimental.