search

rossmann-engineering / EasyModbusTCP.NET

Modbus TCP, Modbus UDP and Modbus RTU client/server library for .NET implementations
922 stars 396 forks source link

Performance issues on Linux / NET5 because of System.IO.Ports #57

Open sandervandegeijn opened 3 years ago

sandervandegeijn commented 3 years ago

As reported over here: https://github.com/dotnet/runtime/issues/2379

When using on Linux / .NET core 5 (not formally supported yet, still it works) the cpu usage of Modbus RTU is terrible, barely usable. I'm talking half a core to do 3 requests/sec to some slave devices. The implementation of System.IO.Ports is not good, which is not a problem on WIndows (no cpu usage at all), but on Linux it goes through the roof.

Testing / using it: https://github.com/neographikal/Modbus2Mqtt

sandervandegeijn commented 3 years ago

I switched out the default implementation with the Mono implementation, but on Windows this resulted in non functional serial communication.

elclaudio commented 3 years ago

hi Could you explain how to set it up to compile and run the examples on http://easymodbustcp.net/codesampleseasymodbustcp-net ? I'm trying to compile and run them on a raspberry pi 4 which should poll a modbus slave. I could not choose net5 and if I select framework 4, it compile, but when I run it under linux it crash: Unhandled Exception: System.TimeoutException: No Response from Modbus Slave at EasyModbus.ModbusClient.ReadHoldingRegisters (System.Int32 startingAddress, System.Int32 quantity) [0x00817] in <8140caba19fe49389617683c5fa07156>:0 at EasyModbus.ModbusClient.ReadHoldingRegisters (System.Int32 startingAddress, System.Int32 quantity) [0x00831] in <8140caba19fe49389617683c5fa07156>:0 at EasyModbus.ModbusClient.ReadHoldingRegisters (System.Int32 startingAddress, System.Int32 quantity) [0x00831] in <8140caba19fe49389617683c5fa07156>:0 at EasyModbus.ModbusClient.ReadHoldingRegisters (System.Int32 startingAddress, System.Int32 quantity) [0x00831] in <8140caba19fe49389617683c5fa07156>:0 at modbustest3.Program.Main (System.String[] args) [0x00043] in <28b1a9dd07c24554a2210d774c0a8882>:0 [ERROR] FATAL UNHANDLED EXCEPTION: System.TimeoutException: No Response from Modbus Slave at EasyModbus.ModbusClient.ReadHoldingRegisters (System.Int32 startingAddress, System.Int32 quantity) [0x00817] in <8140caba19fe49389617683c5fa07156>:0 at EasyModbus.ModbusClient.ReadHoldingRegisters (System.Int32 startingAddress, System.Int32 quantity) [0x00831] in <8140caba19fe49389617683c5fa07156>:0 at EasyModbus.ModbusClient.ReadHoldingRegisters (System.Int32 startingAddress, System.Int32 quantity) [0x00831] in <8140caba19fe49389617683c5fa07156>:0 at EasyModbus.ModbusClient.ReadHoldingRegisters (System.Int32 startingAddress, System.Int32 quantity) [0x00831] in <8140caba19fe49389617683c5fa07156>:0 at modbustest3.Program.Main (System.String[] args) [0x00043] in <28b1a9dd07c24554a2210d774c0a8882>:0

The test app work under windows just fine, but I need it to run under linux !