rpietro / OlecranonFracture

This study describes an interobserver agreement study about image interpretation of olecranon fractures
1 stars 1 forks source link

how should we group agreement results? #13

Open rpietro opened 12 years ago

rpietro commented 12 years ago

is there any way other than bland-altman plots?

do we create three major plots clustering the results for (a) 1d vs. 30d, (b) specialist vs. non-specialist and (c) a comparison across the different scales? i don't think that the overlap among them would be bad, but how do we present this in a way that is both informative as well as aesthetically pleasing?

joaovissoci commented 12 years ago

Made some tests here, not quite there yet, but we can either:

1 - Plot in the same plot area but with different colors for different categories or different symbols;

2 - Plot different plots for each category, in the same plot area or with some customization

Keep trying here and I'll get back to you

2012/6/21 Ricardo Pietrobon < reply@reply.github.com

is there any way other than bland-altman plots?

do we create three major plots clustering the results for (a) 1d vs. 30d, (b) specialist vs. non-specialist and (c) a comparison across the different scales? i don't think that the overlap among them would be bad, but how do we present this in a way that is both informative as well as aesthetically pleasing?


Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub: https://github.com/rpietro/OlecranonFracture/issues/13

Joao Ricardo N. Vissoci Psicólogo CRP 08/12469 Prof. Ms. Faculdade Ingá Doutorando em Psicologia Social - PUCsp Grupo Pro-Esporte UEM/CNPq Núcleo de Estudos e Pesquisas sobre Identidade-Metamorfose - NEPIM/PUC/CNPq Research on Research Group - RoR - Duke University Tel. 4499298078 joaovissoci@gmail.com/jrvissoci@ig.com.br proesporteuem.blogspot.com.br researchonresearch.org

rpietro commented 12 years ago

cool, can you provide some code or insert the plots?

On Fri, Jul 13, 2012 at 12:31 AM, Joao Ricardo N Vissoci < reply@reply.github.com

wrote:

Made some tests here, not quite there yet, but we can either:

1 - Plot in the same plot area but with different colors for different categories or different symbols;

2 - Plot different plots for each category, in the same plot area or with some customization

Keep trying here and I'll get back to you

2012/6/21 Ricardo Pietrobon < reply@reply.github.com

is there any way other than bland-altman plots?

do we create three major plots clustering the results for (a) 1d vs. 30d, (b) specialist vs. non-specialist and (c) a comparison across the different scales? i don't think that the overlap among them would be bad, but how do we present this in a way that is both informative as well as aesthetically pleasing?


Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub: https://github.com/rpietro/OlecranonFracture/issues/13

Joao Ricardo N. Vissoci Psicólogo CRP 08/12469 Prof. Ms. Faculdade Ingá Doutorando em Psicologia Social - PUCsp Grupo Pro-Esporte UEM/CNPq Núcleo de Estudos e Pesquisas sobre Identidade-Metamorfose - NEPIM/PUC/CNPq Research on Research Group - RoR - Duke University Tel. 4499298078 joaovissoci@gmail.com/jrvissoci@ig.com.br proesporteuem.blogspot.com.br researchonresearch.org


Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub: https://github.com/rpietro/OlecranonFracture/issues/13#issuecomment-6954483