Ignoring antialiasing does not work correctly

[DudaGod]

Hello guys.

How do you think these images are equivalent if you want to ignore antialiasing?

Expected behaviour: comparison with tolerance 2.3 and with ignore antialiasing

[jamescryer]

Apologies for the very late response. The ignore antialiasing mode is more tolerant of colour difference, in this case though I agree that it's a little too tolerant.

https://github.com/rsmbl/Resemble.js/blob/master/resemble.js#L879

It think its fair to say it should only use the increased tolerance mode on pixels identified as "anti-aliased" rather than all pixels. Any change in behaviour in this regard would probably require a major release.

[rodrigo-garcia-leon]

Hey, is this issue still relevant? and if so can I work on it? 🧐

[jamescryer]

@rodrigo-garcia-leon Of course, although it may take me a while to review any changes.

[rodrigo-garcia-leon]

Excellent 👌

[rodrigo-garcia-leon]

Hi @jamescryer,

I've been reading the code to understand the issue and come up with possible solutions. I have three ideas in mind:

1. Lower the tolerance thresholds in https://github.com/rsmbl/Resemble.js/blob/master/resemble.js#L981
2. Create an intermediate setting with different tolerance thresholds
3. Allow the definition of the thresholds via the options object

Additionally, there's the improvement that you mentioned; use the increased tolerance mode only on pixels identified as "anti-aliased".

Not sure how to proceed, what do you think?

[asterium]

Hi @rodrigo-garcia-leon, It's offtopic for this specific bug, however option 3 mentioned will be very useful feature. Please let me know if I should open separate issue in order to implement it

[RossNE99]

Is this still an issue, im having a similar problem when I have enabled ignore antialiasing, it seems to be somewhat working but it is highlighting some areas in grey instead of the specified color

Diffrence only mode

Ignore less disabled