search

rsmp-nordic / rsmp_sxl_traffic_lights

RSMP Signal Exchange List (SXL) for Traffic Controllers
MIT License
12 stars 4 forks source link

Commands M0010, M0011, M0012 are all Reserved in version 1.1 (deprecated?) #162

Open sveitech opened 1 year ago

sveitech commented 1 year ago

Has these commands been deprecated in version 1.1 of the SXL? all are marked as "reserved". In the older versions the commands are fully described.

otterdahl commented 1 year ago

They are marked as reserved (for future use).

These commands were originally intended for use with the coordination spec to start/stop signal groups. However, there were still questions remaining how they should be interpreted. As you might remember, we ended using M0006/M0013 (set input) instead for coordination. But we kept M0010,M0011,M0012 anyway, in hopes that we could clarify them in the future. Since we don't actively use them, they are marked "reserved" until further notice.

It is still possible to view the full description in the YAML SXL file in the rsmp_schema repo, which we use to generate the documentation.

emiltin commented 1 year ago

@sveitech did this answer your question?

sveitech commented 1 year ago

@emiltin I take it to mean that the objects are not in use and should not be implemented by suppliers?

emiltin commented 1 year ago

Right, the commands M0010,M0011,M0012 are "reserved", and should not be used or implemented.