search

rstrouse / ESPSomfy-RTS

A controller for Somfy RTS shades and blinds
The Unlicense
567 stars 39 forks source link

Weird Home Assistant Controls behaviours #41

Closed isngofoz closed 1 year ago

isngofoz commented 1 year ago

Firstly, thanks for your efforts on this solution. It certainly helped with automating my Somfy roller shutters with Home Assistant.

However there are sometimes some weird behaviours from the Home Assistant controls. For example, I push the Up button in HA to raise the shutter, it goes all the way up, stops for a few seconds and then for some reason comes back down to an almost closed position on its own. The Up button appears still masked out, so the only way to gain control/sync again is to press the Down button in HA, which then closes the shutter fully and then I can raised the shutter again using the Up button.

The weird part is that it does not happen all the time, just on occasions and usually when I have left the ESP on idle for some time (ie not used it for a day or logged into the webUI).

I have just updated the firmware and application to v1.5.2 to see if it fixes the problem as I recalled updating the HA Add-on recently so maybe there is some fixes.

On that note, is it difficult to add another entity to show that there is a new firmware update available?

afmaniacc commented 1 year ago

Hi i have the same Problem, do you found a solution for that? but iam on Firmware 1.5.1

rstrouse commented 1 year ago

Can I get both of you to try something for me. With the shades completely stopped. Press the my button on the remote. If the shade moves I may know what it going on. Are these shades set up as roller shades, draperies, or blinds? If they are blinds what type has been selected for the motor type?

On that note, is it difficult to add another entity to show that there is a new firmware update available?

I'll have a look to see if I can figure something out here.

isngofoz commented 1 year ago

To be honest, I usually only used the MY button as a 'Stop' button on the remote.

Anyways, I tried according to what you said and interestingly enough, I believe the shutter moved to that position I described above, almost closed but not closed. Mine are metal roller shutters so I choose Roller Shade as the type.

rstrouse commented 1 year ago

Ok so press the my button and let the shutter move to that position. After it is done moving hold down the my button on the remote until it jogs.

011V32 commented 1 year ago

I also have the behavior from time to time (also directly in the ESPSomfyRTS web interface). But I was not sure if it was related to the fact that at the end (0% or 100%) the My position was also controlled... (This then only occurs when the time is greater than the blinds shutdown time.)

isngofoz commented 1 year ago

Ok so press the my button and let the shutter move to that position. After it is done moving hold down the my button on the remote until it jogs.

Okay, done. How does this solve the issue?

rstrouse commented 1 year ago

This removes the my position that ESPSomfy-RTS is not currently aware of. Next you need to update your firmware and application to 1.5.3 which does not issue a stop (my) command when the motor is expected to go to its limits.

rstrouse commented 1 year ago

If you want to set a my position, set it first with ESPSomfy RTS by holding down the my button on the ESPSomfy RTS app until the Set My Position screen opens. Move the slider to the new my position then press Set My Position. The motor will move to this position and stop then it will jog indicating the my position is set.

From here on out if the motor is idle and you press the my button, it will move to the set position.

isngofoz commented 1 year ago

If you want to set a my position, set it first with ESPSomfy RTS by holding down the my button on the ESPSomfy RTS app until the Set My Position screen opens. Move the slider to the new my position then press Set My Position. The motor will move to this position and stop then it will jog indicating the my position is set.

For some reason, after clicking the Set My Position button, the motor moves to the position that I usually like the shutter to stop at but it does not jog. The My Position does get updated though but when I click My button the on-screen shutter simulates a move but the actual shutter stays put. This is running v1.5.3 . image

I also tried it today on v1.5.2 and it also did not jog as well when setting the My position. It seems to me that there is an issue setting the My position using ESPSomfy. I just tried setting the My position with the remote and it worked.

rstrouse commented 1 year ago

Thanks, I will have another look at that code. It may not be holding the signal long enough. It will be fixed in the next release.

isngofoz commented 1 year ago

Thanks for responding back so quickly.

I hope you don't mind me thinking out loud. I have learnt from above that the My Button should only be pressed (held) when the shutter is at idle to set the My Position. However with the ESPSomfy, the Set My Position is done in one click. Is it possible that the code is sending the My Position too early while the shutter is still moving?

Either way, thanks for checking. I will monitor the post and test the update when it is available.

rstrouse commented 1 year ago

Nope it appears that it needs to repeat the command much longer than it is once it makes it to the my position destination. Originally I assumed it only needed to hold for 15 repeats but it appears it needs to do it for 25.

rstrouse commented 1 year ago

v1.5.4 fixes your My button woes.

isngofoz commented 1 year ago

Hi there, thanks. Yes, it definitely did solve the My settings.

Not a big deal but I did noticed that 55% in Home Assistant works out to be 45% when I was setting the My position. But I guess My Position isn't exactly used HA anyways so once it is setup, it doesn't really matter.

rstrouse commented 1 year ago

That is correct. The Home Assistant cover is displayed in percentage of open and cannot be changed without completely rewriting the cover domain component. I cannot find words to describe how ridiculous that is but at some point I will recode the Home Assistant interface to use my own cover domain.

This means the 55% closed it 45% open in Home Assistant. Hard to complain when it is open source and I need to rework it so it works logically. I love Home Assistant but that really does put the ass in the assistant. Is my type A showing?

isngofoz commented 1 year ago

As you mentioned, it is open source and free, so probably all it needs is just a simple note that when setting My position based on a desired position in HA, to get the same position, you need to use 100% - the HA % and that's what you want to set.

Either way, as per my first post above, thanks for your awesome solution. It has allowed me to automate my shutters to open up after sunrise when someone is at home and motion is detected, but if I jump on my bed during the day (bed has FSR sensors), the shutters will automatically closed down.

Happy for you to close this issue.

rstrouse commented 1 year ago

I now dub you @isngofoz knight of crazy home automationville. Not throwing stones I am a long time resident.