kevinushey
commented
7 months ago Thanks for the bug report -- I wasn't able to reproduce locally, though. I tried the following:
# simulate version of arrow in the cellar
dir.create("renv/cellar", recursive = TRUE)
download.packages("arrow", destdir = "renv/cellar")
# get renv to dump information about installed packages
trace(renv:::renv_install_impl, quote({
str(records)
}))
trace(renv:::r_cmd_install, quote({
print(ls.str())
stop("aborting install", call. = FALSE)
}))
# attempt installation
options(repos = NULL)
Sys.setenv(ARROW_S3="ON", ARROW_DEPENDENCY_SOURCE="BUNDLED", ARROW_OFFLINE_BUILD="true")
renv::install("arrow@15.0.1", repos = NULL, prompt = FALSE)And here, I saw:
> renv::install("arrow@15.0.1", repos = NULL, prompt = FALSE)
- Package arrow [15.0.1] will be installed from the cellar.
The following package(s) will be installed:
- arrow [15.0.1]
These packages will be installed into "~/Library/R/arm64/4.3/library".
Tracing renv_install_impl(records) on entry
List of 1
$ arrow:List of 4
..$ Package: chr "arrow"
..$ Version: chr "15.0.1"
..$ Source : chr "Repository"
..$ Path : Named chr "/Users/kevin/r/pkg/renv/renv/cellar/arrow_15.0.1.tar.gz"
.. ..- attr(*, "names")= chr "source"
# Installing packages --------------------------------------------------------
- Installing arrow ... Tracing r_cmd_install(package, path) on entry
package : chr "arrow"
path : chr "/Users/kevin/r/pkg/renv/renv/cellar/arrow_15.0.1.tar.gz"
FAILEDSo renv should be using the Cellar here. Can you share the output of renv::diagnostics(), just in case you have some local configuration that might be relevant here?
hutch3232
For context my
Renvironment is behind a firewall, so I don't have access to the outside internet. However, I do have access to a mirror of CRAN.I use the very convenient
renvcellar to store in-house packages as well as a handful of external packages that rely on external dependencies. For the latter, I have to do the build outside of the firewall and then place them in the cellar for later use.What I found is that
renv::installrecognizes the package in my cellar, and says it will be installed from there. Then, for some reason it goes to CRAN and downloads the tarball from there and installs that one, instead of mine in the cellar. This is a problem because my tarball has all the source dependencies bundled, per: https://arrow.apache.org/docs/r/reference/create_package_with_all_dependencies.htmlI know it says it was successful, but if you run
arrow::arrow_info()I see that it did not install all the optional dependencies, like S3 support which is included in my bundle.I attempted to prevent
renvfrom accessing CRAN (my mirror):Another thing I tried to do was use the
renvshim ofinstall.packages. This used to work for me but had some odd behavior this time:I had a partial success by downgrading to
renv0.17.3 (this was arbitrary, I didn't try in-between version).The issue here was that for some reason the package did not end up moving to my cache, it just installed directly to my project folder.
Happy to try troubleshooting anything else.