search

rtcweb-wg / rtcweb-transport

draft-ietf-rtcweb-transport
2 stars 2 forks source link

Configuration choice - guidance? #37

Closed alvestrand closed 7 years ago

alvestrand commented 7 years ago

From Spencer Dawkins in IESG review:

I agree with

There exist a number of schemes for achieving quality of service that do not depend solely on DSCP code points. Some of these schemes depend on classifying the traffic into flows based on 5-tuple (source address, source port, protocol, destination address, destination port) or 6-tuple (5-tuple + DSCP code point). Under differing conditions, it may therefore make sense for a sending application to choose any of the configurations:

and the text that follows it, but I'm not understanding how a sending application would know which configuration to choose, if we're still talking about downloaded Javascript on an arbitrary browser instance (is that still accurate? If not, my apologies).

Is the sending application just guessing/applying heuristics, or is there any guidance (or a reference to guidance) you can provide?

alvestrand commented 7 years ago

My emailed response:

I don't think we have the experience that could form the basis for guidance yet, so my suggestion is "no change".

alvestrand commented 7 years ago

Since there's been no further input here, I'm closing this as "no change needed".