rzach / forallx-yyc

UCalgary version of forallx, an introduction to formal logic
https://forallx.openlogicproject.org/
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International
94 stars 30 forks source link

Update a few exercises that used \tnd #19

Closed wyleyr closed 7 years ago

wyleyr commented 7 years ago

Finally got a chance to look into replacing the uses of TND in the solutions manual with the new rules. Here's a PR that gives new proofs for a couple of exercises in the TFL section of the book.

It didn't occur to me until after I did a few that we don't have to replace every use of TND, since it's still a derived rule. At least the proof for the exercise in chapter 15 needs to be replaced; but you might want to forget the two commits for the chapter 17 exercises, if you're OK with appeals to \tnd in chapter 17.

Should I work on any more of these?

rzach commented 7 years ago

Thanks!